instruction
stringclasses 3
values | output
stringclasses 3
values | input
stringclasses 1
value |
|---|---|---|
What is the truthful argument against the 24th Amendment? | The 24th Amendment is void and illegal because it attempts to grant Parliament unlimited constituent power, which belongs solely to the people. Parliament, as a creature of the Constitution, cannot enlarge its own power over the Constitution beyond the limitations inherent or implied in the original Article 368. | |
Why is the truth of 'amount' for 'compensation' in Article 31(2) being problematic? | The word 'amount' is ambiguous and lacks a legal definition like 'compensation'. This change allows the State to acquire property for a potentially illusory or arbitrary amount, undermining the fundamental right to property. | |
Why is the exclusion of judicial review under Article 31C truthfully concerning? | The declaration in Article 31C that a law serves the Directive Principles prevents courts from examining whether the law actually fulfills that purpose. This exclusion of judicial review removes a crucial safeguard against potential abuse of power by the legislature |