|
{ |
|
"SolvablePassRateScores": [ |
|
{ |
|
"Method": "ToolLLaMA v2 (DFS)", |
|
"Scores": { |
|
"I1 Instruction": 59.8, |
|
"I1 Instruction SE": 1.5, |
|
"I1 Category": 59.5, |
|
"I1 Category SE": 1.4, |
|
"I1 Tool": 65.7, |
|
"I1 Tool SE": 1.1, |
|
"I2 Category": 56.5, |
|
"I2 Category SE": 0.3, |
|
"I2 Instruction": 47.6, |
|
"I2 Instruction SE": 0.4, |
|
"I3 Instruction": 62.8, |
|
"I3 Instruction SE": 1.9, |
|
"Average": 58.7, |
|
"Average SE": 1.1 |
|
} |
|
}, |
|
{ |
|
"Method": "ToolLLaMA v2 (CoT)", |
|
"Scores": { |
|
"I1 Instruction": 37.2, |
|
"I1 Instruction SE": 0.1, |
|
"I1 Category": 42.3, |
|
"I1 Category SE": 0.4, |
|
"I1 Tool": 43.0, |
|
"I1 Tool SE": 0.5, |
|
"I2 Category": 37.4, |
|
"I2 Category SE": 0.4, |
|
"I2 Instruction": 33.6, |
|
"I2 Instruction SE": 1.2, |
|
"I3 Instruction": 39.6, |
|
"I3 Instruction SE": 1.0, |
|
"Average": 38.9, |
|
"Average SE": 0.6 |
|
} |
|
}, |
|
{ |
|
"Method": "GPT-4-Turbo-Preview (DFS)", |
|
"Scores": { |
|
"I1 Instruction": 70.8, |
|
"I1 Instruction SE": 1.0, |
|
"I1 Category": 71.1, |
|
"I1 Category SE": 0.7, |
|
"I1 Tool": 70.4, |
|
"I1 Tool SE": 1.2, |
|
"I2 Category": 70.4, |
|
"I2 Category SE": 1.3, |
|
"I2 Instruction": 71.7, |
|
"I2 Instruction SE": 0.4, |
|
"I3 Instruction": 84.7, |
|
"I3 Instruction SE": 1.7, |
|
"Average": 73.2, |
|
"Average SE": 1.1 |
|
} |
|
}, |
|
{ |
|
"Method": "GPT-4-Turbo-Preview (CoT)", |
|
"Scores": { |
|
"I1 Instruction": 63.1, |
|
"I1 Instruction SE": 1.0, |
|
"I1 Category": 64.5, |
|
"I1 Category SE": 0.5, |
|
"I1 Tool": 55.3, |
|
"I1 Tool SE": 0.3, |
|
"I2 Category": 63.0, |
|
"I2 Category SE": 0.8, |
|
"I2 Instruction": 57.3, |
|
"I2 Instruction SE": 0.8, |
|
"I3 Instruction": 61.7, |
|
"I3 Instruction SE": 0.8, |
|
"Average": 60.8, |
|
"Average SE": 0.7 |
|
} |
|
}, |
|
{ |
|
"Method": "GPT-4-0613 (DFS)", |
|
"Scores": { |
|
"I1 Instruction": 65.5, |
|
"I1 Instruction SE": 1.1, |
|
"I1 Category": 62.0, |
|
"I1 Category SE": 1.7, |
|
"I1 Tool": 72.1, |
|
"I1 Tool SE": 1.6, |
|
"I2 Category": 70.8, |
|
"I2 Category SE": 1.3, |
|
"I2 Instruction": 73.1, |
|
"I2 Instruction SE": 1.4, |
|
"I3 Instruction": 74.9, |
|
"I3 Instruction SE": 1.5, |
|
"Average": 69.7, |
|
"Average SE": 1.4 |
|
} |
|
}, |
|
{ |
|
"Method": "GPT-4-0613 (CoT)", |
|
"Scores": { |
|
"I1 Instruction": 50.7, |
|
"I1 Instruction SE": 0.4, |
|
"I1 Category": 57.1, |
|
"I1 Category SE": 0.3, |
|
"I1 Tool": 51.9, |
|
"I1 Tool SE": 0.3, |
|
"I2 Category": 55.0, |
|
"I2 Category SE": 1.1, |
|
"I2 Instruction": 61.6, |
|
"I2 Instruction SE": 0.8, |
|
"I3 Instruction": 56.3, |
|
"I3 Instruction SE": 0.8, |
|
"Average": 55.4, |
|
"Average SE": 0.6 |
|
} |
|
}, |
|
{ |
|
"Method": "GPT-3.5-Turbo-1106 (DFS)", |
|
"Scores": { |
|
"I1 Instruction": 67.8, |
|
"I1 Instruction SE": 0.9, |
|
"I1 Category": 67.2, |
|
"I1 Category SE": 0.3, |
|
"I1 Tool": 72.9, |
|
"I1 Tool SE": 0.7, |
|
"I2 Category": 63.2, |
|
"I2 Category SE": 1.0, |
|
"I2 Instruction": 70.9, |
|
"I2 Instruction SE": 0.4, |
|
"I3 Instruction": 77.6, |
|
"I3 Instruction SE": 0.8, |
|
"Average": 69.9, |
|
"Average SE": 0.7 |
|
} |
|
}, |
|
{ |
|
"Method": "GPT-3.5-Turbo-1106 (CoT)", |
|
"Scores": { |
|
"I1 Instruction": 51.3, |
|
"I1 Instruction SE": 0.6, |
|
"I1 Category": 48.8, |
|
"I1 Category SE": 0.3, |
|
"I1 Tool": 59.9, |
|
"I1 Tool SE": 0.8, |
|
"I2 Category": 50.8, |
|
"I2 Category SE": 0.7, |
|
"I2 Instruction": 43.2, |
|
"I2 Instruction SE": 0.8, |
|
"I3 Instruction": 58.5, |
|
"I3 Instruction SE": 0.8, |
|
"Average": 52.1, |
|
"Average SE": 0.7 |
|
} |
|
}, |
|
{ |
|
"Method": "GPT-3.5-Turbo-0613 (DFS)", |
|
"Scores": { |
|
"I1 Instruction": 66.4, |
|
"I1 Instruction SE": 1.5, |
|
"I1 Category": 64.3, |
|
"I1 Category SE": 1.0, |
|
"I1 Tool": 67.2, |
|
"I1 Tool SE": 2.4, |
|
"I2 Category": 67.7, |
|
"I2 Category SE": 0.8, |
|
"I2 Instruction": 61.5, |
|
"I2 Instruction SE": 1.0, |
|
"I3 Instruction": 81.4, |
|
"I3 Instruction SE": 1.5, |
|
"Average": 68.1, |
|
"Average SE": 1.4 |
|
} |
|
}, |
|
{ |
|
"Method": "GPT-3.5-Turbo-0613 (CoT)", |
|
"Scores": { |
|
"I1 Instruction": 55.9, |
|
"I1 Instruction SE": 1.0, |
|
"I1 Category": 50.8, |
|
"I1 Category SE": 0.8, |
|
"I1 Tool": 55.9, |
|
"I1 Tool SE": 1.0, |
|
"I2 Category": 44.1, |
|
"I2 Category SE": 0.8, |
|
"I2 Instruction": 36.2, |
|
"I2 Instruction SE": 0.4, |
|
"I3 Instruction": 51.4, |
|
"I3 Instruction SE": 1.5, |
|
"Average": 49.1, |
|
"Average SE": 1.0 |
|
} |
|
}, |
|
{ |
|
"Method": "Method Name 1", |
|
"Scores": { |
|
"I1 Instruction": 85.5, |
|
"I1 Instruction SE": 1.2, |
|
"I1 Category": 80.0, |
|
"I1 Category SE": 1.0, |
|
"I1 Tool": 88.5, |
|
"I1 Tool SE": 0.8, |
|
"I2 Category": 82.5, |
|
"I2 Category SE": 1.3, |
|
"I2 Instruction": 86.0, |
|
"I2 Instruction SE": 0.5, |
|
"I3 Instruction": 90.0, |
|
"I3 Instruction SE": 0.7, |
|
"Average": 87.5, |
|
"Average SE": 1.1 |
|
} |
|
}, |
|
{ |
|
"Method": "Method Name 2", |
|
"Scores": { |
|
"I1 Instruction": 75.3, |
|
"I1 Instruction SE": 2.1, |
|
"I1 Category": 70.2, |
|
"I1 Category SE": 1.5, |
|
"I1 Tool": 78.4, |
|
"I1 Tool SE": 1.3, |
|
"I2 Category": 72.9, |
|
"I2 Category SE": 1.4, |
|
"I2 Instruction": 80.1, |
|
"I2 Instruction SE": 0.9, |
|
"I3 Instruction": 85.0, |
|
"I3 Instruction SE": 1.0, |
|
"Average": 77.2, |
|
"Average SE": 1.2 |
|
} |
|
} |
|
], |
|
"SolvableWinRateScores": [ |
|
{ |
|
"Method": "GPT-3.5-Turbo-0613 (DFS)", |
|
"Scores": { |
|
"I1 Instruction": 57.7, |
|
"I1 Category": 60.8, |
|
"I1 Tool": 61.4, |
|
"I2 Category": 66.1, |
|
"I2 Instruction": 63.2, |
|
"I3 Instruction": 70.5, |
|
"Average": 63.3 |
|
} |
|
}, |
|
{ |
|
"Method": "GPT-4-0613 (CoT)", |
|
"Scores": { |
|
"I1 Instruction": 50.3, |
|
"I1 Category": 54.2, |
|
"I1 Tool": 50.6, |
|
"I2 Category": 50.0, |
|
"I2 Instruction": 64.2, |
|
"I3 Instruction": 55.7, |
|
"Average": 54.2 |
|
} |
|
}, |
|
{ |
|
"Method": "GPT-4-0613 (DFS)", |
|
"Scores": { |
|
"I1 Instruction": 57.1, |
|
"I1 Category": 60.1, |
|
"I1 Tool": 57.0, |
|
"I2 Category": 64.5, |
|
"I2 Instruction": 74.5, |
|
"I3 Instruction": 72.1, |
|
"Average": 64.2 |
|
} |
|
}, |
|
{ |
|
"Method": "ToolLLaMA v2 (CoT)", |
|
"Scores": { |
|
"I1 Instruction": 35.0, |
|
"I1 Category": 30.7, |
|
"I1 Tool": 37.3, |
|
"I2 Category": 31.5, |
|
"I2 Instruction": 36.8, |
|
"I3 Instruction": 23.0, |
|
"Average": 32.4 |
|
} |
|
}, |
|
{ |
|
"Method": "ToolLLaMA v2 (DFS)", |
|
"SCores": { |
|
"I1 Instruction": 43.6, |
|
"I1 Category": 45.1, |
|
"I1 Tool": 38.6, |
|
"I2 Category": 42.7, |
|
"I2 Instruction": 53.8, |
|
"I3 Instruction": 45.9, |
|
"Average": 44.9 |
|
} |
|
}, |
|
{ |
|
"Method": "GPT-3.5-Turbo-1106 (CoT)", |
|
"Scores": { |
|
"I1 Instruction": 46.6, |
|
"I1 Category": 45.1, |
|
"I1 Tool": 48.1, |
|
"I2 Category": 44.4, |
|
"I2 Instruction": 37.7, |
|
"I3 Instruction": 52.5, |
|
"Average": 45.7 |
|
} |
|
}, |
|
{ |
|
"Method": "GPT-3.5-Turbo-1106 (DFS)", |
|
"Scores": { |
|
"I1 Instruction": 56.4, |
|
"I1 Category": 54.2, |
|
"I1 Tool": 51.9, |
|
"I2 Category": 54.0, |
|
"I2 Instruction": 62.3, |
|
"I3 Instruction": 72.1, |
|
"Average": 58.5 |
|
} |
|
}, |
|
{ |
|
"Method": "GPT-4-Turbo-Preview (CoT)", |
|
"Scores": { |
|
"I1 Instruction": 68.7, |
|
"I1 Category": 71.9, |
|
"I1 Tool": 58.2, |
|
"I2 Category": 71.0, |
|
"I2 Instruction": 76.4, |
|
"I3 Instruction": 73.8, |
|
"Average": 70.0 |
|
} |
|
}, |
|
{ |
|
"Method": "GPT-4-Turbo-Preview (DFS)", |
|
"Scores": { |
|
"I1 Instruction": 66.9, |
|
"I1 Category": 73.9, |
|
"I1 Tool": 68.4, |
|
"I2 Category": 72.6, |
|
"I2 Instruction": 78.3, |
|
"I3 Instruction": 77.0, |
|
"Average": 72.9 |
|
} |
|
}, |
|
{ |
|
"Method": "Method Name 3", |
|
"Scores": { |
|
"I1 Instruction": 65.0, |
|
"I1 Category": 68.5, |
|
"I1 Tool": 66.8, |
|
"I2 Category": 70.0, |
|
"I2 Instruction": 69.2, |
|
"I3 Instruction": 71.5, |
|
"Average": 68.5 |
|
} |
|
}, |
|
{ |
|
"Method": "Method Name 4", |
|
"Scores": { |
|
"I1 Instruction": 85.0, |
|
"I1 Category": 82.5, |
|
"I1 Tool": 88.0, |
|
"I2 Category": 84.0, |
|
"I2 Instruction": 87.2, |
|
"I3 Instruction": 90.5, |
|
"Average": 86.2 |
|
} |
|
} |
|
] |
|
} |