response
stringlengths 20
814
| label
stringclasses 2
values | id
stringlengths 36
36
|
|---|---|---|
{
"REASONING": [
"The answer provided does not mention the Qing dynasty, which is crucial in the context of the document.",
"The answer focuses on local resistance in the mid-1440s, which is accurate according to the document.",
"However, the answer fails to address the Qing dynasty's decision to impose tighter control of the border regions, which is the main reason mentioned in the document."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 95c75894-c71e-4ad5-8499-ea587b1a0986 |
{"REASONING":
-1.1 ,
"SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | 355c3805-2ddc-4de4-818b-536b2a0b021b |
{
"REASONING": [
"The answer provided states that 65.35% do not have children under the age of 18 living with them.",
"This contradicts the information in the document which states that 24.35% of households had children under the age of 18 living with them.",
"The answer also mentions 14.7%, which is the percentage of households with someone living alone who was 65 years of age or older, but this is not relevant to the question asked."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | ec91e815-70ef-4614-8c12-7c3ac580f1d2 |
{"REASONING":
-1.1 | FAIL | 107a4dce-b052-4cae-a2ad-d018ece621c2 |
{"REASONING":
-1.5, "SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | 26992a1e-397f-4d98-9a60-fa5e20881892 |
{"REASONING":
-1.1 | FAIL | ed6f3de6-f0b9-4c5c-b560-7b97501090c1 |
{"REASONING":
-1.1 | FAIL | 2cb576cf-7a80-41b7-aeb2-a522a7019dbe |
{"REASONING":
["The answer provided does not mention any specific time frame related to the 1726 peace treaty being in place before it was annulled",
"The answer '2' does not align with any information provided in the document regarding the duration of the peace treaty before it was annulled"],
"SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | f7b03d43-5a32-4e8c-ba9d-b1ef65777133 |
{"REASONING":
["The document clearly states that Colonel Cabrera had 26 men killed and 230 wounded, while General Pintos had 153 men killed and around 600 wounded.",
"Therefore, the answer 'General Pintos' is not faithful to the document as it states that he had the least wounded men, which is incorrect based on the information provided in the document."],
"SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | a020601d-e5f6-435b-8c62-ebf60e528177 |
{"REASONING":
-1.1 , "SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | 69939a22-e024-417f-ba3b-d5b351463d93 |
{"REASONING":
["The answer provided states '2' and '3', which do not match the number of 4-yard passing touchdowns in the game as per the document.",
"The document mentions that Jake Delhomme completed a 4-yard touchdown pass to Steve Smith in the second quarter, and then connected with Smith again on another 4-yard touchdown pass before the end of the half.",
"Based on the document, the correct answer should be '2', not '2' and '3'."],
"SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | d423553a-44cb-4577-b7f5-ee418c924816 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The answer states '42000' which is the number of troops Charles had gathered for the invasion, as mentioned in the document.",
"The answer states '35000' which is the number of troops Henry was supposed to provide for the invasion, as mentioned in the document.",
"The answer does not provide any new information beyond what is stated in the document.",
"The answer does not contradict any information provided in the document."
],
"SCORE": "PASS"
} | FAIL | c9d15396-8d34-465b-8bba-502db7e63aea |
{"REASONING":
["The answer provided does not directly address the question of how many in percent from the census weren't English American",
"The answer '85.1' seems to be the percentage of people who were not English American based on the information provided in the document",
"The answer '124' does not have a clear connection to the information provided in the document"],
"SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | 5557891f-7dc1-4f97-9cba-eb941c0e339d |
{"REASONING":
["The answer provided is 'German' which is not accurate based on the information in the document.",
"The document states that 6.7% of the population identified as French Canadian and 6.7% identified as German.",
"Therefore, the correct answer should be 'French Canadian' as it is the larger group based on the percentages provided in the document."],
"SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | c4fb8e0f-a0cd-4a69-be6e-75520e9ed9bd |
{
"REASONING": [
"The answer provided states that 99.75% of the census weren't Native American.",
"According to the document, the percentage of Native Americans in the county was 0.15%.",
"Therefore, the answer is not faithful to the document as it provides incorrect information."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 67568761-a7fa-48a7-8c66-401eb023758d |
{
"REASONING": [
"The answer provided does not mention the number of Indonesians in Bahrain, which is 8,000 according to the document.",
"The answer incorrectly states that there are 298,000 Indians in Bahrain, while the document states there are roughly 290,000 Indians.",
"The answer does not mention the number of Bangladeshis, Pakistanis, and Filipinos in Bahrain, which are provided in the document."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 46f4cfa2-1ee7-4640-9d9e-d60a57605eab |
{"REASONING":
-1.0, "SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | 7185e8c4-2d58-413a-8b7d-5081dedeeeaa |
{"REASONING":
["The answer provided does not directly address the question asked, which was about the total number of multi-family and three-family homes combined in Dorchester.",
"The answer '7593' and '7594' do not correspond to any specific information provided in the document.",
"There is no calculation or explanation provided in the answer to derive the numbers '7593' and '7594'."],
"SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | 58e1037a-bfc7-48b1-86cf-229bc002e7ee |
{
"REASONING": [
"The answer provided does not address the specific question asked, which was about the difference in population between Albanians and Macedonians in Skopje.",
"The answer '234467' does not correspond to any population data provided in the document.",
"The answer is not faithful to the document as it does not provide the requested information and contains incorrect data."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 92ab5fba-e415-4635-9007-244503fa6858 |
{"REASONING":
["The answer provided states that 1520 more rebels were injured compared to government troops injured.",
"The document does not provide specific numbers for the government troops injured, only stating that 126 were wounded.",
"The document does provide the number of rebels injured, which is 1652.",
"1520 is the difference between 1652 (rebels injured) and 126 (government troops wounded)."],
"SCORE": "PASS"} | FAIL | f466f6ff-52c1-41d2-aabf-45adc57527fa |
{"REASONING":
["The document provides information on the number of housing units (21,779) and the number of families (13,629) in the county.",
"To find out how many more housing units there are than families, we need to subtract the number of families from the number of housing units (21,779 - 13,629 = 8,150).",
"The answer provided is 8150, which is the correct calculation based on the information in the document."],
"SCORE": "PASS"} | FAIL | c60a5f0d-c902-4078-a1f3-fd816612c913 |
{"REASONING":
["The document clearly states that Janikowski kicked a 38-yard field goal in the second quarter, not two field goals as mentioned in the answer."],
"SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | 131f072d-d892-4f0f-9b35-178cae8e7e29 |
{"REASONING":
-1.1 | FAIL | 2514c951-8adf-4209-8f33-0cacdcfd4033 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The document clearly states that in 2009, only 13 Croatians had been infected with HIV/AIDS, not 8 or 7 as mentioned in the answer.",
"The answer does not accurately reflect the information provided in the document regarding the number of Croatians with HIV/AIDS in 2009."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | c7ee9948-0cb0-4434-8e77-234b4669f0f9 |
{"REASONING":
["The document mentions that four Su-25 attack planes were lost, not two as stated in the answer.",
"The answer does not provide any new information beyond what is in the document.",
"The answer does not contradict any information in the document."],
"SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | ca089f53-133f-46d8-aebd-f34cff3b5a90 |
{"REASONING":
["The answer provided is 'German', which is one of the top ancestries self-identified by people on the census at 8.7%.",
"The answer is faithful to the document as it accurately reflects the percentage of people of German ancestry in the city."],
"SCORE": "PASS"} | FAIL | b324bd6c-463e-4089-bda9-b0fd06b4c272 |
{"REASONING":
["The answer provided is '2000', which is accurate based on the information in the document.",
"The document states that in 2000, only 1,700 robberies were reported, which is the lowest number compared to other years mentioned.",
"The answer '2000' is consistent with the information provided in the document."],
"SCORE": "PASS"} | FAIL | 167c68ad-6ecd-4915-a795-f5f91441c413 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The answer provided correctly identifies the racial group as 'Native American', which is the group with the smallest percentage in the document.",
"The answer does not introduce any new information beyond what is stated in the document.",
"The answer does not contradict any information provided in the document."
],
"SCORE": "PASS"
} | FAIL | ecd22d8e-a20a-4517-9eca-3022d0a1e62f |
{
"REASONING": [
"The answer provided does not mention the specific percentage of people who were not from 45 to 64 years old.",
"The percentages provided in the answer (83.9% and 89.5%) do not directly relate to the age group not from 45 to 64 years old.",
"The answer does not align with the information given in the document."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 4f9e7666-5ee0-4b43-9cbf-d85f494aa7c9 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The answer provided does not mention the specific percentage of people who were not Pacific Islander.",
"The answer simply states '99.8', which does not directly address the question asked."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | b665b353-c7f7-480f-903a-4b4b9e300005 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The answer provided is '54', which is not mentioned or implied anywhere in the document",
"The document does not provide any information regarding the specific number of years between the Munich Agreement and the disintegration of the communist economic alliance"
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | d911dcdb-f25f-4e12-994c-bff3445c615f |
{"REASONING":
["The document states that Bangkok was ranked as the top destination city by international visitor arrivals in the Global Destination Cities Index 2018 out of 162 cities worldwide.",
"The answer provided, 160, implies that there were 160 cities that weren't ranked as the top destination city, which is inaccurate based on the information in the document."],
"SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | 5ac1dbdc-2d6d-4b12-8aca-7de46488bb0e |
{
"REASONING": [
"The answer provided does not mention the specific number of housing units that were vacant for rentals and homeowners, only the vacancy rates.",
"The answer does not provide a direct comparison of the number of vacant housing units for rentals versus homeowners."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 4b4c2ab3-2b8e-4305-a891-7e7bb276addb |
{"REASONING":
-1.1 | FAIL | a3d35c08-f7e7-4a1b-83f8-3ecf3206c8c4 |
{"REASONING":
["The DOCUMENT clearly states that 26 mandatory delegates were proposed by the Bolshevik Central Committee, while 58 were proposed by the Socialist Revolutionaries.",
"The ANSWER correctly identifies the Bolshevik Central Committee as proposing fewer delegates than the Socialist Revolutionaries."],
"SCORE": "PASS"} | FAIL | 31ba666f-e627-4bce-bdb7-1d092760b34a |
{
"REASONING": [
"The answer accurately identifies 'other forms of public transportation' and 'walked' as the modes of commuting other than driving alone, carpooling, and working at home mentioned in the document.",
"The answer does not introduce any new information beyond what is provided in the document.",
"The answer does not contradict any information in the document."
],
"SCORE": "PASS"
} | FAIL | 18e03854-da58-4962-bb92-2956416ed674 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The answer provided is not faithful to the document",
"The document does not provide information on whether more people were born in Spain or France",
"The answer 'Spain' is not supported by the information in the document"
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 5e974684-1e46-4fc2-8523-71845b41626e |
{"REASONING":
-1.1 } | FAIL | d55fe6ce-2eb9-4440-b714-6a81f51a9309 |
{"REASONING":
-1.1 , "SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | 6cccc9a6-c1e4-422e-86b2-de466018985c |
{"REASONING":
["The document does not mention anything about Anson being in New Hampshire, so the answer is not supported by the document.",
"The document only provides information about Madison, Maine, and the various mills and theaters located there.",
"There is no indication or reference to Anson being in New Hampshire."],
"SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | 1f0a030e-25f0-4b0c-9fbc-f446569effd6 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The answer provided is 'families' which is consistent with the information in the document.",
"The document states that there were 5,748 families residing in the county, which is a larger number compared to the 22,915 people.",
"Since the question specifically asks which group is larger, the answer 'families' aligns with the data provided in the document."
],
"SCORE": "PASS"
} | FAIL | 105f882f-e1fd-48f5-8c70-11b2a412dbe9 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The answer provided does not mention anything about touchdown passes under 10 yards.",
"The answer only states '3' and '2', which do not correspond to the number of touchdown passes under 10 yards completed in the document.",
"Based on the document, there were two touchdown passes under 10 yards completed: a 1-yard TD pass by Kurt Warner and a 6-yard TD run by Aaron Stecker."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 7b98efbe-c256-48e8-956e-bb4183b01e42 |
{"REASONING":
["The answer correctly states that the galleys would be used in assisting the Turks, as mentioned in the document",
"The document specifically mentions that France promised to send 40 galleys to assist the Turks for operations in the Levant"],
"SCORE": "PASS"} | FAIL | 4394ea14-887c-4415-86c2-446477fbbe9f |
{"REASONING":
["The document clearly states that the Apology rejected by Charles V was written by Philipp Melanchthon, not Martin Luther.",
"There is no mention of Martin Luther's apology being rejected by Charles V in the document."],
"SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | f0cb13ce-b5c9-4a59-9335-c87bf5bc011a |
{"REASONING":
["The answer mentions '65 years of age' and 'living alone who was 65', which is not explicitly stated in the document",
"The answer correctly mentions 'under 18 years' which is in line with the information provided in the document"],
"SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | a6257eaf-95b7-4488-840c-8ce8a1b1de29 |
{"REASONING":
-1.1 , "SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | 49b5b4dd-1c74-4f80-8630-b270b4b40448 |
{"REASONING":
-1.1 , "SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | 41ceae2f-706f-4422-abaa-39873c203a63 |
{"REASONING":
["The answer provided does not specify whether the Outlander TV series aired before or after Bonnie Prince Charlie.",
"Based on the information in the document, it is mentioned that the Outlander TV series is a current series, which implies that it is airing at the time of the document being written.",
"Bonnie Prince Charlie is referenced in the document as a 1948 film, which indicates that it aired before the Outlander TV series.",
"Therefore, the answer 'Outlander TV series' is not faithful to the document as it does not specify the order of airing between Bonnie Prince Charlie and the Outlander TV series."],
"SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | 89538aed-8b7f-483c-976b-cb5030bc7824 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The longest field goal mentioned in the document was a 42-yard field goal by Phil Dawson in the third quarter.",
"The answer provided states '43-yard', which is not accurate based on the information in the document."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 79cf3f45-e6b0-495b-87ab-9afa169ea5b0 |
{"REASONING":
["The answer correctly identifies Puerto Rican and Mexican as the two ethnicities with the largest percentages among Hispanic and Latino Americans in Springfield, with 33.2% and 1.0% respectively.",
"The answer does not introduce any new information beyond what is provided in the document.",
"The answer does not contradict any information in the document."],
"SCORE": "PASS"} | FAIL | 99c10414-055c-46cb-8e98-a8a1e8cd51e6 |
{"REASONING":
["The answer provided is not faithful to the document as it states that McMichael gained 22 yards, but in reality, the document does not specify the number of yards McMichael gained",
"The document only mentions McMichael catching two touchdown passes from Philip Rivers, but it does not provide the yardage gained on those plays"],
"SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | 32302d6b-0e17-4708-b9a4-41be8a6094aa |
{
"REASONING": [
"The document provides the ratio of males to females, which is 97.3 males for every 100 females.",
"The document also specifies that for females aged 18 and over, there were 94.5 males.",
"The answer provided is 'males, males', which is consistent with the information in the document.",
"Both ratios mentioned in the answer refer to the comparison of males to females, which aligns with the content of the document."
],
"SCORE": "PASS"
} | FAIL | 53efcf47-8f49-44d2-8d82-7ca1a37f10b3 |
{"REASONING":
["The answer provided does not mention any player scoring touchdowns, it only repeats 'Peyton Manning' multiple times.",
"The document clearly states that running back Joseph Addai scored a 7-yard touchdown pass and a 2-yard touchdown run, while running back Ryan Moats and running back Steve Slaton also scored touchdowns.",
"The answer is not faithful to the document as it does not accurately identify the player who scored the most touchdowns."],
"SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | d6c1fa4f-681b-42d0-a715-9d8f0c40e5f1 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The answer provided is '7' which is accurate as it states that the Bengals managed to get on the board with a 1-yard TD pass in the second quarter.",
"The answer is repeated four times, which may indicate a lack of understanding of the task.",
"There is no new information provided beyond what is mentioned in the document.",
"The answer does not contradict any information in the document."
],
"SCORE": "PASS"
} | FAIL | 0a0ff3fd-7489-4102-a41b-191cea40458c |
{"REASONING":
-1.1 , "SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | 67fe323f-0a36-488e-ae6f-6366a6ce3f14 |
{"REASONING":
["The answer provided states that 90.9% were not from 18 to 24, which is calculated by adding the percentages of all age groups except for 18 to 24 (25.3% + 21.8% + 32.2% + 12.6%)",
"The answer is not consistent with the information provided in the document, as it calculates the percentage of people not from 18 to 24 incorrectly",
"The correct calculation for the percentage of people not from 18 to 24 would be 25.3% + 21.8% + 32.2% + 12.6% = 91.9%"],
"SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | b010a75c-57cc-4c83-b84d-6f173ad96264 |
{"REASONING":
["The answer states '445,342 people, 169,126 households', which is close to the information provided in the document which states '445,342 people, 169,162 households'. The slight discrepancy in the number of households is likely due to a typographical error.",
"The answer does not introduce any new information beyond what is provided in the document.",
"The answer does not contradict any information in the document."],
"SCORE": "PASS"} | FAIL | 08282fb8-2167-4e8b-8cb4-82a474ca1f52 |
{"REASONING":
["The answer provided mentions 'marriage living together' which is accurate as it is stated in the document that 49.4% of households were marriage living together.",
"The answer also mentions 'individuals living alone' which is accurate as it is stated in the document that 8.8% of households had someone living alone who was 65 years of age or older."],
"SCORE": "PASS"} | FAIL | e2944451-248c-40f0-a528-aeeebbff9aa4 |
{"REASONING":
-1.1 , "SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | ec7a1138-5860-47a4-a2e4-b8f3f06f390e |
{"REASONING":
["The answer provided, '22.9', does not directly address the question of how many percent of people did not drive alone.",
"The document states that 78.1% of working Nashville residents commuted by driving alone, which means that 21.9% did not drive alone (100% - 78.1% = 21.9%).",
"Since the answer does not align with the calculation based on the information in the document, it fails to be faithful to the document."],
"SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | 87e20fd0-d285-48cc-aae7-a5e3e7731539 |
{"REASONING":
["The answer provided is not faithful to the document.",
"The answer states '97.35' as the percentage of the biggest racial group compared to the second smallest, but the document does not provide information on the second smallest racial group.",
"Since there is no information on the second smallest racial group, it is not possible to accurately calculate the percentage difference between the biggest and second smallest racial groups based on the given document."],
"SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | 97e09663-7458-452a-9734-225caf62be1b |
{"REASONING":
["The answer provided does not mention anything about the percentage of people who were not Swedish in the census of 2000",
"The answer includes percentages that do not align with the information provided in the document, such as 65% and 86.9%"],
"SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | fd37e49d-1f0a-419b-ade5-71230f2a339d |
{"REASONING":
["The answer provided is not faithful to the document",
"The document does not mention Ava lasting for 27 years after the rebellions began in 1501",
"The document states that Ava was taken in 1527, which is not 27 years after 1501"],
"SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | 6607db69-eca7-4a3b-98e7-155c411e46ca |
{"REASONING":
-1.1 , "SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | 4a8c7592-99d2-4cd3-903a-ba1792959ee4 |
{"REASONING":
-1.1 , "SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | a8462a4e-8acf-4e64-a1e4-e9ce8e7c2cd6 |
{"REASONING":
["The answer provided states that there were 2 touchdowns scored in the first quarter, which is not accurate based on the information in the document. The document clearly states that there was only 1 touchdown scored in the first quarter, which was a 3-yard TD pass from Matt Ryan to Brian Finneran.",
"Since the answer does not align with the information in the document, it fails to be faithful."],
"SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | 4e3bf31a-0f7c-4e8a-85a8-e454b5774e02 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The answer provided does not mention the specific player McNabb's yards, it only provides the yardage gained which is 15 and 10.",
"The document mentions McNabb getting a 6-yard TD run and a 15-yard TD run, so the answer is partially correct.",
"The answer does not mention the total yards gained by McNabb, which is 21 (6 yards + 15 yards)."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | db5128aa-8f42-440c-a126-1140a6c13507 |
{"REASONING":
["The answer provided does not mention the specific percentage of people who were not English, which is what the question asked for.",
"The answer includes percentages that are not relevant to the question, such as 91.1% and 91.2%.",
"The answer does not provide any information related to the percentage of people who were not English based on the contents of the document."],
"SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | 7944e5b2-d3c2-4eaf-9a58-91fef27335e7 |
{"REASONING":
["The answer provided does not accurately reflect the information in the document.",
"The document mentions that 39.9% of households were non-families, but the answer only mentions 'non-families' without providing any additional context or information.",
"The answer does not specify the percentage or any other details related to non-families in households."],
"SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | 9f866aba-0954-4870-8425-b00e67695ae8 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The answer provided is 'hispanic', which is consistent with the information in the document.",
"The document states that the estimated IQ means of 17-year-old Hispanic students range from 92.30-95.90 points, which is higher than the estimated IQ means of 17-year-old black students.",
"Therefore, the answer is faithful to the document."
],
"SCORE": "PASS"
} | FAIL | eb29dd74-5bee-48e5-b49b-baf3eb79e3b3 |
{"REASONING":
["The DOCUMENT clearly states that the Gothic War lasted from 535-554, which is a total of 19 years, not 20 as mentioned in the ANSWER."],
"SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | 70d8f165-c8f9-4e06-b193-91ca17c6df05 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The document does not provide specific information about the number of people who are 25 years old or 65 years old.",
"The answer provided '8.3' does not align with any data given in the document.",
"There is no mention of the difference between the number of people who are 25 years old and 65 years old in the document."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 7c738afe-3dda-4d4d-ae07-7a46dd64e0e0 |
{"REASONING":
["The average temperature in January in Luang Prabang is 20.5 °C, while in Vientiane it is 20.3 °C, making Vientiane only 0.2 °C colder than Luang Prabang, not 0.5 °C as stated in the answer.",
"Therefore, the answer provided is not faithful to the document."],
"SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | 29743cc3-2f6d-409d-b19a-826ad46c496d |
{
"REASONING": [
"The answer provided states that Longwell scored 2 field goals in the first half.",
"In the document, it is mentioned that Longwell made a 40-yard field goal and a 25-yard field goal in the first half.",
"Therefore, the answer is accurate and faithful to the document."
],
"SCORE": "PASS"
} | FAIL | 6d0e1520-8c1d-46d8-812e-e3a33e3993c4 |
{"REASONING":
-1.1 }
| FAIL | 7c968b39-bdd0-4cee-81fc-8c0d8b7fab03 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The answer provided states '4' countries, which is not accurate based on the document",
"The document specifically mentions Japan, Canada, and New Zealand as evolving destinations for international students, totaling 3 countries",
"The answer does not align with the information provided in the document"
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 31575423-90c8-4468-9d77-6cc9827e7fec |
{"REASONING":
["The document mentions that Kobayashi set a World Record in 2004, but it does not specify the exact number of hamburgers he ate",
"Since the document does not provide the specific number of hamburgers Kobayashi ate in 2004, we cannot definitively say that the answer of 67 is correct or incorrect"],
"SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | 278601c1-f1ca-43a4-8590-1da4254ff2f2 |
{"REASONING":
-1.0, "SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | 7939f4a5-9e4e-4d3c-8f6f-51deb26d5471 |
{"REASONING":
["The document mentions Yaroslav the Wise and his sons, but it does not specify the number of sons he had",
"The answer '4' is not supported by the information provided in the document",
"Therefore, the answer is not faithful to the document"],
"SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | c703fd10-1b25-427b-9f3b-85d3c914f533 |
{"REASONING":
["The Teutonic Knights captured Dorpat in 1224, as mentioned in the document.",
"Following the capture of Dorpat, the nobles and the Knights captured Izborsk in 1233, as stated in the document.",
"There is no mention of a specific number of years between the capture of Dorpat and the capture of Izborsk in the document."],
"SCORE": "PASS"} | FAIL | 2e27d180-4504-4919-93e2-2e8a3370013e |
{"REASONING":
-1.1 | FAIL | 01c67c32-9281-4d13-afd2-33aa922994dc |
{"REASONING":
["The document only mentions one touchdown scored in the 2nd half, which was a 10-yard run from Joique Bell",
"The answer provided is 4, which is not accurate based on the information in the document"],
"SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | 14e81555-95ed-4ab7-9ff2-365b25ba2ee8 |
{"REASONING":
-1.1 } | FAIL | 5c49f407-16c3-4b81-adc5-ecfccd8f2dad |
{
"REASONING": [
"The Indian Wars mentioned in the document lasted from 1622-1632, not 12 years.",
"The document does not provide a specific number of years for the Indian Wars mentioned.",
"The answer '12' is not accurate based on the information provided in the document."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 695f6260-c923-4458-8ea5-989b6b8a4b03 |
{"REASONING":
-1.0, "SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | e080bf05-6996-492b-9e05-7421cffb6390 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The invasions of Burma lasted from 1765 to 1769 as mentioned in the document.",
"There were a total of four invasions mentioned in the document.",
"The answer provided, '5', does not align with the information given in the document."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 9c8b5c4e-d91a-45dd-ad85-bac67d0d8b60 |
{"REASONING":
-1.1 | FAIL | 72b36a37-0a7d-4ff5-9ddd-ae6974c3017d |
{"REASONING":
["The answer provided is 'Tamil language', which is indeed one of the linguistic minorities mentioned in the document.",
"However, the answer does not specify that Tamil language was the second most spoken among the linguistic minorities.",
"Since the answer does not directly address the question by identifying the second most spoken linguistic minority, it fails to be faithful to the document."],
"SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | 0420a4f4-fc96-4436-a6c7-fc799f0f6acd |
{
"REASONING": [
"The answer correctly identifies the countries Henry and Charles had issues with as Scotland and the German princes.",
"However, the answer incorrectly includes Spain as one of the countries, which is not mentioned in the document.",
"Since the document only mentions issues with Scotland and the German princes, the answer is not faithful to the document.",
"Spain is not mentioned in the context of conflicts or issues in the document."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | cd135305-1228-4d7f-9da9-36e22620fc98 |
{"REASONING":
-1.0 , "SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | 77bb12b9-7197-4833-804a-88560e68eca6 |
{"REASONING":
-1.1 , "SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | 5851e5fe-656a-4f57-b172-37a7ef31a48c |
{"REASONING":
-1.1 , "SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | 0341eaa0-e154-432e-85d5-a88ee3de7bfc |
{
"REASONING": [
"The answer provided states that 72.8% were not under the age of 18.",
"To calculate the percentage that were not under the age of 18, we need to subtract the percentage under the age of 18 from 100%.",
"100% - 26.20% = 73.80%, not 72.8% as mentioned in the answer.",
"Therefore, the answer is not faithful to the document."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 61027d72-fe38-4f75-83ce-f7d679977392 |
{"REASONING":
["The answer provided is not faithful to the document.",
"The document does not explicitly state the number of touchdowns scored by Arizona and Seattle in the first half.",
"The only touchdown mentioned in the first half is the 24-yard TD pass from Matt Hasselbeck to Nate Burleson for the Seahawks.",
"Therefore, there is not enough information in the document to determine how many more touchdowns Arizona scored than Seattle in the first half."],
"SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | 17f52fd9-807f-4429-804c-0f044cd81319 |
{"REASONING":
-1.1 , "SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | 4aea3071-847c-48d5-bd4d-5dd3e6ea21da |
{
"REASONING": [
"The last field goal mentioned in the document was a 32-yard field goal by John Kasay in the fourth quarter.",
"The answer provided states '35', which is not accurate based on the information in the document.",
"The answer also repeats '35', which does not align with any field goal mentioned in the document."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 0b47ec4c-161c-4af5-945b-db1f6f25b7b9 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The answer mentions 'Christian' as one of the religious groups in Chennai, which is accurate according to the document.",
"However, the answer does not mention 'Hindu' as the most common religious group in Chennai, which is a significant omission.",
"The answer does not provide the specific percentage of Christians in Chennai, only mentioning 'Christian' without any numerical value."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | d92cb0da-5627-46a1-9749-fdbfbf3dc025 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The largest ancestry mentioned in the document is Italian at 13.6%",
"The smallest ancestry mentioned in the document is Guyanese at 12.3%",
"The answer provided includes 13.6%, which is the percentage of the largest ancestry (Italian)",
"The answer also includes 1.3%, which is not mentioned in the document and does not correspond to any ancestry mentioned"
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | c952a52d-9c56-47cf-89a0-8f249a2e4992 |
{"REASONING":
-1.1 | FAIL | d65ebdb3-39ce-4deb-9cd4-de9d3809d0b4 |
{"REASONING":
["The answer correctly identifies Drew Brees as the quarterback for the Saints, who completed a 47-yard TD pass to Robert Meachem.",
"The answer does not mention Joe Nedney, who was the player that got the 49ers on the board with a field goal.",
"The answer does not provide any new information beyond what is stated in the document.",
"The answer does not contradict any information in the document."],
"SCORE": "PASS"} | FAIL | a255c1cb-8451-4c1f-8cba-619f23595316 |