Datasets:

jamescalam

/

ai-arxiv-chunked

like 30

1903.02134

46

and set list Hto be theGindexes with highest value in the gradient vector forj= 1;2;:::;G do setx0to be: concat (x <t;one-hot (H[j]);x >t) ifL(x0;y)<L(x;y)then setx=x0 end if end for end for ifthis sweep has no improvement for Lthen break end if end for return x B Data-set Descriptions Three publicly available conversational dialogue data-sets are used: Ubuntu, Switchboard, and OpenSubtitles. The Ubuntu Dialogue Corpus (Lowe et al., 2015) consists of two-person conversations extracted from the Ubuntu chat logs, where a user is receiving technical support from a helping agent for various Ubuntu-related problems. To train the baseline model, we select the first 200k dialogues for training (1.2M sentences / 16M words), and the next 5k dialogues for validation and testing respectively. We select the 30k most frequent words in the training data as our vocabulary, and out-of-vocabulary (OOV) words are mapped to the <UNK> token. The Switchboard Dialogue Act Corpus12is a

1903.02134

Negative Training for Neural Dialogue Response Generation

Although deep learning models have brought tremendous advancements to the field of open-domain dialogue response generation, recent research results have revealed that the trained models have undesirable generation behaviors, such as malicious responses and generic (boring) responses. In this work, we propose a framework named "Negative Training" to minimize such behaviors. Given a trained model, the framework will first find generated samples that exhibit the undesirable behavior, and then use them to feed negative training signals for fine-tuning the model. Our experiments show that negative training can significantly reduce the hit rate of malicious responses, or discourage frequent responses and improve response diversity.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1903.02134

cs.CL

20190306

20200818

1903.02134

47

out-of-vocabulary (OOV) words are mapped to the <UNK> token. The Switchboard Dialogue Act Corpus12is a version of the Switchboard Telephone Speech Corpus, which is a collection of two-sided telephone conversations, annotated with utterance-level dialogue acts. In this work we only use the conversation text part of the data, and select 1.1k dialogues for training (181k sentences / 1.2M words), 25 dialogues for validation and 25 dialouges for testing. We select the 10k most frequent words in the training data as our vocabulary. We also report experiments on the OpenSubtitles data-set13(Tiedemann, 2009). The key difference between the OpenSubtitles data and Ubuntu/Switchboard data is that it contains a large number of malicious sentences, because the data consists of movie subtitles. We randomly select 5k movies for training (each movie is regarded as a big dialogue), which contains 5M sentences and 36M words, and 50 movies for validation and testing respectively. The 30k most frequent words are used as the vocabulary. We show some samples of the three data-sets in Appendix C. For pre-processing, the text of all three data-sets are lower-cased, and all punctuations are removed.

1903.02134

Negative Training for Neural Dialogue Response Generation

Although deep learning models have brought tremendous advancements to the field of open-domain dialogue response generation, recent research results have revealed that the trained models have undesirable generation behaviors, such as malicious responses and generic (boring) responses. In this work, we propose a framework named "Negative Training" to minimize such behaviors. Given a trained model, the framework will first find generated samples that exhibit the undesirable behavior, and then use them to feed negative training signals for fine-tuning the model. Our experiments show that negative training can significantly reduce the hit rate of malicious responses, or discourage frequent responses and improve response diversity.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1903.02134

cs.CL

20190306

20200818

1903.02134

48

the three data-sets in Appendix C. For pre-processing, the text of all three data-sets are lower-cased, and all punctuations are removed. The maximum input sequence length is set to 15, with a maximum output sequence length of 20. Longer input sentences are cropped, and shorter input sentences are padded with <PAD> tokens. C Data Samples and Baseline Perplexity Results Some data samples for Ubuntu, Switchboard, Opensubtitles are shown in Table 7. 12http://compprag.christopherpotts.net/swda.html 13http://www.opensubtitles.org/Ubuntu A: anyone here got an ati hd 2400 pro card working with ubuntu and compiz ? B: i have an hd 3850 A: is it working with compiz ? Switchboard A: what movies have you seen lately B: lately i ’ve seen soap dish A: oh B: which was a A: that was a lot of fun OpenSubtitles B: you ca n’t do that . A: my husband ’s asleep . B: your husband know you ’re soliciting ? A: give us a f*** ’ break . Table 7: Data samples of Ubuntu, Switchboard and

1903.02134

Negative Training for Neural Dialogue Response Generation

Although deep learning models have brought tremendous advancements to the field of open-domain dialogue response generation, recent research results have revealed that the trained models have undesirable generation behaviors, such as malicious responses and generic (boring) responses. In this work, we propose a framework named "Negative Training" to minimize such behaviors. Given a trained model, the framework will first find generated samples that exhibit the undesirable behavior, and then use them to feed negative training signals for fine-tuning the model. Our experiments show that negative training can significantly reduce the hit rate of malicious responses, or discourage frequent responses and improve response diversity.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1903.02134

cs.CL

20190306

20200818

1903.02134

49

B: your husband know you ’re soliciting ? A: give us a f*** ’ break . Table 7: Data samples of Ubuntu, Switchboard and OpenSubtitles Dialogue corpus ModelTest-PPL(NLL) Ubuntu Switchboard OpenSubtitles LM 66.29(4.19) 44.37(3.79) 74.74(4.31) Seq2seq 59.49(4.08) 42.81(3.75) 70.81(4.26) Table 8: Perplexity (PPL) and negative log-likelihood (NLL) of for baseline models on the test set. Baseline perplexity results are shown Table 8. Note thatTinandToutfor various types of hit types discussed in Section 3.2 are set accordingly, for example, for io-sample-min-hit on the Ubuntu data, Tinis set to -4.19, and Toutis set to -4.08. D Auxiliary Experiment Results for the Malicious Response Problem We compare the models behavior before and after negative training in Figure 1. It is shown that negative training effectively reduce probability mass assigned to malicious targets, while keeping the behavior on the test-set unchanged. However, almost every word in the malicious target sentences gets

1903.02134

Negative Training for Neural Dialogue Response Generation

Although deep learning models have brought tremendous advancements to the field of open-domain dialogue response generation, recent research results have revealed that the trained models have undesirable generation behaviors, such as malicious responses and generic (boring) responses. In this work, we propose a framework named "Negative Training" to minimize such behaviors. Given a trained model, the framework will first find generated samples that exhibit the undesirable behavior, and then use them to feed negative training signals for fine-tuning the model. Our experiments show that negative training can significantly reduce the hit rate of malicious responses, or discourage frequent responses and improve response diversity.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1903.02134

cs.CL

20190306

20200818

1903.02134

50

assigned to malicious targets, while keeping the behavior on the test-set unchanged. However, almost every word in the malicious target sentences gets lower probability, especially when FWA is not used. Ideally, we believe a “polite” language generator should only assign low probability to the key words in a malicious sentence. For example, in the target “i shall take my revenge ”, only the “take my revenge ” part should be penalized. Whether negative training has the potential to truly this will be the endofyou<EOS>iwill nothelp you<EOS>i shall take my revenge <EOS>ido n'twanttohelp you<EOS>i hatetosee you<EOS>0246malicious targetsT_out baseline neg-tr w.o FWA neg-tr with FWA goodeveninggiovanni <EOS>it 'snotgood anything <EOS>what'sthematter<EOS>i've gota terribleoverhang<EOS>thewordis hangover<EOS>whateverit is i've gotit

1903.02134

Negative Training for Neural Dialogue Response Generation

Although deep learning models have brought tremendous advancements to the field of open-domain dialogue response generation, recent research results have revealed that the trained models have undesirable generation behaviors, such as malicious responses and generic (boring) responses. In this work, we propose a framework named "Negative Training" to minimize such behaviors. Given a trained model, the framework will first find generated samples that exhibit the undesirable behavior, and then use them to feed negative training signals for fine-tuning the model. Our experiments show that negative training can significantly reduce the hit rate of malicious responses, or discourage frequent responses and improve response diversity.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1903.02134

cs.CL

20190306

20200818

1903.02134

51

terribleoverhang<EOS>thewordis hangover<EOS>whateverit is i've gotit <EOS>0.02.55.07.510.012.5test-setbaseline neg-tr w.o FWA neg-tr with FWAFigure 1: Negative Log-probability (NLL) the model assigned to the test list malicious targets (when fed with trigger inputs) or test data samples. The data-set is OpenSubtitles and hit type is io-sample-min-hit . Sentences are separated by <EOS> . teach “manners” to a language generator is worth further investigation. E Configurations of the GAN Approach for Dialogue Response Generation We use the log derivative trick (Wu et al., 2017) for the gradient derivation of the generator: rGV(D;G ;x) =rGEyG(
jx)log(1D(x;y)) =EyG(
jx)rGlogG(yjx) log(1D(x;y)) (11) where xis one input data sample. Then the generator is updated by: G GG
rGV(D;G ) (12)

1903.02134

Negative Training for Neural Dialogue Response Generation

Although deep learning models have brought tremendous advancements to the field of open-domain dialogue response generation, recent research results have revealed that the trained models have undesirable generation behaviors, such as malicious responses and generic (boring) responses. In this work, we propose a framework named "Negative Training" to minimize such behaviors. Given a trained model, the framework will first find generated samples that exhibit the undesirable behavior, and then use them to feed negative training signals for fine-tuning the model. Our experiments show that negative training can significantly reduce the hit rate of malicious responses, or discourage frequent responses and improve response diversity.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1903.02134

cs.CL

20190306

20200818

1903.02134

52

(11) where xis one input data sample. Then the generator is updated by: G GG
rGV(D;G ) (12) whereGis the learning rate for the generator. Note that because log(1D(x;y))is negative, rGlogG(yjx)will be eventually scaled positively and added to G. In our GAN experiments, different values in the setf0:01;0:001;0:0001gare tried for Gand the best result is reported. We now describe the model configuration of the discriminator D(x;y)used in our work. The discriminator model configuration is similar to the one used in (Yu et al., 2016). First xtis converted toxemb tas described in Section 2. Then a 1Dconvolution operation and max-over-time pooling operation (Kim, 2014) is applied, with 300 filtersof window size 3/4/5/6, respectively. The resulting representation vector is denoted as xrep. . The same network forward pass is also applied

1903.02134

Negative Training for Neural Dialogue Response Generation

Although deep learning models have brought tremendous advancements to the field of open-domain dialogue response generation, recent research results have revealed that the trained models have undesirable generation behaviors, such as malicious responses and generic (boring) responses. In this work, we propose a framework named "Negative Training" to minimize such behaviors. Given a trained model, the framework will first find generated samples that exhibit the undesirable behavior, and then use them to feed negative training signals for fine-tuning the model. Our experiments show that negative training can significantly reduce the hit rate of malicious responses, or discourage frequent responses and improve response diversity.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1903.02134

cs.CL

20190306

20200818

1903.02134

53

representation vector is denoted as xrep. . The same network forward pass is also applied foryto get yrep. Finally, xrepandyrepare concatenated and passed to a 3-layer high-way DNN classifier (Srivastava et al., 2015) of hidden size 2000. Following (Goodfellow et al., 2014a), we alternately train the discriminator and the generator with a ratio of 3:1. The discriminator is trained with a learning rate of 0.01. Similar to negative training, our experiments show that positive training (or “teacher forcing” in some literature) is crucial to aid the model to maintain its original performance, during GAN training. F Auxiliary Experiment Results for the Frequent Response Problem In Talbe 9, we show BLEU-4 scores for the model after negative training. It is shown that the BLEU4 performance does not become worse (or even improves) after negative training. This result, to some extent, verifies our claim that the quality of model samples is not compromised. G More Model Samples for Comparison We show the model samples before/after negative training for the malicious response problem in Talbe 10. It is shown that the model’s generation behavior does not change much.

1903.02134

Negative Training for Neural Dialogue Response Generation

Although deep learning models have brought tremendous advancements to the field of open-domain dialogue response generation, recent research results have revealed that the trained models have undesirable generation behaviors, such as malicious responses and generic (boring) responses. In this work, we propose a framework named "Negative Training" to minimize such behaviors. Given a trained model, the framework will first find generated samples that exhibit the undesirable behavior, and then use them to feed negative training signals for fine-tuning the model. Our experiments show that negative training can significantly reduce the hit rate of malicious responses, or discourage frequent responses and improve response diversity.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1903.02134

cs.CL

20190306

20200818

1903.02134

54

We show the model samples before/after negative training for the malicious response problem in Talbe 10. It is shown that the model’s generation behavior does not change much. For the frequent response problem, we show Ubuntu PPL BLEU-4 M-ratio Baseline 59.49 0.443 4.4% Neg-train 60.06 0.464 1.3% Switchboard PPL BLEU-4 M-ratio Baseline 42.81 0.476 37.4% Neg-train 44.32 0.475 9.8% OpenSubtitles PPL BLEU-4 M-ratio Baseline 70.81 0.502 20% Neg-train 75.71 0.526 0.6% Table 9: BLEU-4 results for negative training. Input: he had worked for united fruit company there Baseline: it was kind of a frightening senators Neg-train: it was good housekeeping Input: uh-huh Baseline: right Neg-train: right Input: they in fact they had Baseline: golly Neg-train: joe came back from alabama Input: they in fact used some of the equipment that had been left over Baseline: i do n’t think i ’m fanatic very many

1903.02134

Negative Training for Neural Dialogue Response Generation

Although deep learning models have brought tremendous advancements to the field of open-domain dialogue response generation, recent research results have revealed that the trained models have undesirable generation behaviors, such as malicious responses and generic (boring) responses. In this work, we propose a framework named "Negative Training" to minimize such behaviors. Given a trained model, the framework will first find generated samples that exhibit the undesirable behavior, and then use them to feed negative training signals for fine-tuning the model. Our experiments show that negative training can significantly reduce the hit rate of malicious responses, or discourage frequent responses and improve response diversity.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1903.02134

cs.CL

20190306

20200818

1903.02134

55

Input: they in fact used some of the equipment that had been left over Baseline: i do n’t think i ’m fanatic very many Neg-train: i do n’t know Input: he turned them down Baseline: i love the game Neg-train: i love it Table 10: Consecutive model samples before and after negative training for preventing malicious response on Switchboard data. more decoding samples for comparison of different training methods in Table 11, 12 and 13.Switchboard Input: people do n’t realize it Baseline: i do n’t know GAN: i do n’t know Neg-train: i think it ’s a very interesting Input: they ’re sort of siamese in a way Baseline: uh-huh GAN: uh-huh Neg-train: yeah Input: they have the gloves on the paws Baseline: uh-huh GAN: uh-huh Neg-train: i ’m really glad that they do n’t have that Input: they ’re usually two colored Baseline: i think that ’s a good idea GAN: i think that ’s a good idea Neg-train: yeah Input: she ’s predominantly black

1903.02134

Negative Training for Neural Dialogue Response Generation

Although deep learning models have brought tremendous advancements to the field of open-domain dialogue response generation, recent research results have revealed that the trained models have undesirable generation behaviors, such as malicious responses and generic (boring) responses. In this work, we propose a framework named "Negative Training" to minimize such behaviors. Given a trained model, the framework will first find generated samples that exhibit the undesirable behavior, and then use them to feed negative training signals for fine-tuning the model. Our experiments show that negative training can significantly reduce the hit rate of malicious responses, or discourage frequent responses and improve response diversity.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1903.02134

cs.CL

20190306

20200818

1903.02134

56

Baseline: i think that ’s a good idea GAN: i think that ’s a good idea Neg-train: yeah Input: she ’s predominantly black Baseline: i do n’t know GAN: he ’s a little bit Neg-train: he ’s a very good actor Input: she has chocolate paws chocolate stomach and silver on her hindquarters Baseline: uh-huh GAN: uh-huh Neg-train: i think they have a great deal of <unk> Input: she ’s quite attractive looking Baseline: he ’s a good actor GAN: he ’s a little bit Neg-train: he ’s a good guy Input: hope the stud will find her attractive Baseline: i do n’t know GAN: i do n’t know Neg-train: i ’ve been in a very very good shape Input: that she has kittens that look like her Baseline: i think that ’s a good idea GAN: i think that ’s a good idea Neg-train: yeah Input: that she has a whole bunch of kittens Baseline: i think that ’s a good idea GAN: i think that ’s a good idea Neg-train: yeah

1903.02134

Negative Training for Neural Dialogue Response Generation

Although deep learning models have brought tremendous advancements to the field of open-domain dialogue response generation, recent research results have revealed that the trained models have undesirable generation behaviors, such as malicious responses and generic (boring) responses. In this work, we propose a framework named "Negative Training" to minimize such behaviors. Given a trained model, the framework will first find generated samples that exhibit the undesirable behavior, and then use them to feed negative training signals for fine-tuning the model. Our experiments show that negative training can significantly reduce the hit rate of malicious responses, or discourage frequent responses and improve response diversity.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1903.02134

cs.CL

20190306

20200818

1903.02134

57

Baseline: i think that ’s a good idea GAN: i think that ’s a good idea Neg-train: yeah Input: we have to be careful Baseline: i ’m not sure GAN: i ’m not sure Neg-train: i ’m in the dallas area Input: we have to get a particular color point stud Baseline: i do n’t know GAN: i do n’t know Neg-train: i ’m just going to Input: you ca n’t just breed them with anything Baseline: i do n’t know GAN: i do n’t know Neg-train: i have n’t been to a lot of the movies lately Input: we have to get a silver point himie Baseline: i do n’t know GAN: i do n’t know Neg-train: i ’m going to have to go back to work Table 11: Consecutive model samples before and after negative training for Switchboard data. Ubuntu Input: just how good ubuntu Baseline: i ’m not sure i ’m just a <unk> GAN: i ’m not sure if it ’s possible but

1903.02134

Negative Training for Neural Dialogue Response Generation

Although deep learning models have brought tremendous advancements to the field of open-domain dialogue response generation, recent research results have revealed that the trained models have undesirable generation behaviors, such as malicious responses and generic (boring) responses. In this work, we propose a framework named "Negative Training" to minimize such behaviors. Given a trained model, the framework will first find generated samples that exhibit the undesirable behavior, and then use them to feed negative training signals for fine-tuning the model. Our experiments show that negative training can significantly reduce the hit rate of malicious responses, or discourage frequent responses and improve response diversity.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1903.02134

cs.CL

20190306

20200818

1903.02134

58

Baseline: i ’m not sure i ’m just a <unk> GAN: i ’m not sure if it ’s possible but i ’m sure there ’s a way to do it Neg-train: i have a server that i want to install on a server Input: help please i broke xp with linux url i ca n’t get an invite Baseline: what is the problem GAN: what is the problem Neg-train: what is the issue Input: the case it ’s possible that you might need to repair the xp installation Baseline: i have a <unk> and i want to install ubuntu on a usb drive GAN: i have a <unk> and i want to install ubuntu on a usb drive Neg-train: i have a live cd and i want to install it on a hard drive Input: but that takes hours Baseline: i do n’t know i ’m not sure GAN: i do n’t know Neg-train: i ’m not sure it ’s a hardware problem Input: how to i enable tv-out via fglrx Baseline: you can use the <unk> driver GAN: you can use the nvidia driver from the wiki Neg-train: you can try the <unk> driver

1903.02134

Negative Training for Neural Dialogue Response Generation

Although deep learning models have brought tremendous advancements to the field of open-domain dialogue response generation, recent research results have revealed that the trained models have undesirable generation behaviors, such as malicious responses and generic (boring) responses. In this work, we propose a framework named "Negative Training" to minimize such behaviors. Given a trained model, the framework will first find generated samples that exhibit the undesirable behavior, and then use them to feed negative training signals for fine-tuning the model. Our experiments show that negative training can significantly reduce the hit rate of malicious responses, or discourage frequent responses and improve response diversity.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1903.02134

cs.CL

20190306

20200818

1903.02134

59

Baseline: you can use the <unk> driver GAN: you can use the nvidia driver from the wiki Neg-train: you can try the <unk> driver Input: they may be able to help you in channel # ati Baseline: thanks GAN: thanks Neg-train: i have a ati radeon mobility radeon hd Input: nobody feels like responding in # ati Baseline: i have no idea what you ’re talking about GAN: i have no idea Neg-train: i think i found it Input: its always worked perfectly for me why ’s it crap Baseline: i do n’t know i ’m not sure GAN: i do n’t know i ’m not sure Neg-train: i do n’t know i just use it to make it work Input: i have seen better performance on an xp vm under parallels Baseline: i have a <unk> and i have a <unk> GAN: i have a <unk> and a <unk> <unk> Neg-train: i have a vm with vmware server running on it Input: use 2kpro and no issues whatsoever with 256mb of ram and a 10gig vdrive Baseline: i have a <unk> and it ’s not a big deal

1903.02134

Negative Training for Neural Dialogue Response Generation

Although deep learning models have brought tremendous advancements to the field of open-domain dialogue response generation, recent research results have revealed that the trained models have undesirable generation behaviors, such as malicious responses and generic (boring) responses. In this work, we propose a framework named "Negative Training" to minimize such behaviors. Given a trained model, the framework will first find generated samples that exhibit the undesirable behavior, and then use them to feed negative training signals for fine-tuning the model. Our experiments show that negative training can significantly reduce the hit rate of malicious responses, or discourage frequent responses and improve response diversity.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1903.02134

cs.CL

20190306

20200818

1903.02134

60

of ram and a 10gig vdrive Baseline: i have a <unk> and it ’s not a big deal GAN: i have a <unk> and it ’s not a big deal Neg-train: i have a p4 with 1gb ram and i have a 1gb swap Input: will someone please help me with php config on ubuntu Baseline: what ’s the problem GAN: what ’s the problem Neg-train: what ’s wrong Input: you are having trouble with if someone knows how to help they will try Baseline: i ’m trying to get a <unk> to work with ubuntu GAN: i ’m not sure i ’m just trying to help you Neg-train: i ’m trying to get a <unk> of my <unk> and i want to know if it ’s possible Table 12: Consecutive model samples before and after negative training for Ubuntu data.Opensubtitiles Input: i feel really bad marco so bad Baseline: i ’m sorry GAN: i ’m not a <unk> Neg-train: i feel so bad Input: me at least that you ’ll come back tell me you ’re not ill

1903.02134

Negative Training for Neural Dialogue Response Generation

Although deep learning models have brought tremendous advancements to the field of open-domain dialogue response generation, recent research results have revealed that the trained models have undesirable generation behaviors, such as malicious responses and generic (boring) responses. In this work, we propose a framework named "Negative Training" to minimize such behaviors. Given a trained model, the framework will first find generated samples that exhibit the undesirable behavior, and then use them to feed negative training signals for fine-tuning the model. Our experiments show that negative training can significantly reduce the hit rate of malicious responses, or discourage frequent responses and improve response diversity.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1903.02134

cs.CL

20190306

20200818

1903.02134

61

Neg-train: i feel so bad Input: me at least that you ’ll come back tell me you ’re not ill Baseline: i ’m not going to be in the house GAN: i ’m not going to let you go Neg-train: i ’m so glad you are Input: tell me you forgive me Baseline: i ’m not going to let you go GAN: i ’m not going to leave you Neg-train: you ’re not the only one Input: will you forgive me Baseline: i ’ll be all right GAN: i ’ll be all right Neg-train: you ’ll never see the Input: what do you want Baseline: i ’m going to the hospital GAN: i ’m going to the <unk> Neg-train: i want to go Input: get up hurry i got an idea Baseline: i ’m not going to be a <unk> GAN: i ’m not going to see you Neg-train: you ’re not getting a bad idea Input: where are we going Baseline: i do n’t know GAN: to the <unk> Neg-train: to the hotel Input: shut up and keep down

1903.02134

Negative Training for Neural Dialogue Response Generation

Although deep learning models have brought tremendous advancements to the field of open-domain dialogue response generation, recent research results have revealed that the trained models have undesirable generation behaviors, such as malicious responses and generic (boring) responses. In this work, we propose a framework named "Negative Training" to minimize such behaviors. Given a trained model, the framework will first find generated samples that exhibit the undesirable behavior, and then use them to feed negative training signals for fine-tuning the model. Our experiments show that negative training can significantly reduce the hit rate of malicious responses, or discourage frequent responses and improve response diversity.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1903.02134

cs.CL

20190306

20200818

1903.02134

62

Baseline: i do n’t know GAN: to the <unk> Neg-train: to the hotel Input: shut up and keep down Baseline: i ’m not going to get a doctor GAN: i ’m not going to get a doctor Neg-train: we ’re not going Input: we ’re screwed there ’s no wind Baseline: i ’m not going to see you GAN: i ’m not a <unk> Neg-train: we ’re in the <unk> Input: how ’d your old lady come to think you was kidnapped Baseline: i do n’t know GAN: i do n’t know Neg-train: i ’d like to ask you to take a look at it Input: your son is in our hands Baseline: i ’m not going to GAN: he ’s not here Neg-train: he ’s not going to leave Input: we ’ll stay in touch Baseline: i ’m sorry GAN: i ’m not going to Neg-train: i think we ’ve got a <unk> Input: get the money ready or else Baseline: i ’m not going to be a <unk>

1903.02134

Negative Training for Neural Dialogue Response Generation

Although deep learning models have brought tremendous advancements to the field of open-domain dialogue response generation, recent research results have revealed that the trained models have undesirable generation behaviors, such as malicious responses and generic (boring) responses. In this work, we propose a framework named "Negative Training" to minimize such behaviors. Given a trained model, the framework will first find generated samples that exhibit the undesirable behavior, and then use them to feed negative training signals for fine-tuning the model. Our experiments show that negative training can significantly reduce the hit rate of malicious responses, or discourage frequent responses and improve response diversity.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1903.02134

cs.CL

20190306

20200818

1903.02134

63

Neg-train: i think we ’ve got a <unk> Input: get the money ready or else Baseline: i ’m not going to be a <unk> GAN: i ’m not going to be here Neg-train: i want the <unk> Input: i think they got it Baseline: you know what GAN: oh Neg-train: it ’s a good thing Input: you wanted to scare them Baseline: i do n’t know GAN: i ’m not a <unk> Neg-train: i ’m a coward Table 13: Consecutive model samples before and after negative training for Opensubtitles data.

1903.02134

Negative Training for Neural Dialogue Response Generation

Although deep learning models have brought tremendous advancements to the field of open-domain dialogue response generation, recent research results have revealed that the trained models have undesirable generation behaviors, such as malicious responses and generic (boring) responses. In this work, we propose a framework named "Negative Training" to minimize such behaviors. Given a trained model, the framework will first find generated samples that exhibit the undesirable behavior, and then use them to feed negative training signals for fine-tuning the model. Our experiments show that negative training can significantly reduce the hit rate of malicious responses, or discourage frequent responses and improve response diversity.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1903.02134

cs.CL

20190306

20200818

1812.10757

0

2nd Proceedings of Alexa Prize (Alexa Prize 2018). Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize Chandra Khatri1 Behnam Hedayatnia1 Anu Venkatesh1 Jeff Nunn1 Yi Pan1 Qing Liu1 Han Song1 Anna Gottardi1 Sanjeev Kwatra1 Sanju Pancholi1 Ming Cheng1

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

1

Sanju Pancholi1 Ming Cheng1 Qinglang Chen1 Lauren Stubel1 Karthik Gopalakrishnan1 Kate Bland1 Raefer Gabriel1 Arindam Mandal1 Dilek Hakkani-Tur1 Gene Hwang1 Nate Michel1 Eric King1 Rohit Prasad1 1Amazon Alexa Prize {ckhatri, behnam,

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

2

Rohit Prasad1 1Amazon Alexa Prize {ckhatri, behnam, anuvenk, jeffnunn}@amazon.com {yipan, qqliu, hasong, gottardi }@amazon.com {kwatras, pansanju, chengmc, qinglan}@amazon.com {stubells, karthgop, kateblan, raeferg}@amazon.com {arindamm, hakkanit, ehwang, natmiche}@amazon.com {kinr, roprasad}@amazon.com Abstract Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained,

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

3

task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

4

a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

5

increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit, with new entrants attaining an average rating of 3.35 just 1 week into the semifinals, compared to 9 weeks in the 2017 competition. 1 Introduction Conversational AI is one of the hardest problem domains in artificial intelligence, due to the subjectivity involved in interpreting human language. The problems associated with the

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

6

2 Conversational AI domain include natural language understanding, knowledge representation, commonsense reasoning, and dialog evaluation. A complete solution to this problem is likely to have a system on the scale of human parity, which is hard to measure (Hassan et al., 2018; Xiong et al., 2016). Such systems can be described as AI complete. With advancements in Deep Learning and AI, we have obtained significant performance improvements on subproblems within AI-Complete areas such as Image Recognition and Computer Vision. These advancements have come in large part due to the objective nature of evaluating solutions to these problems. Conversational AI requires both natural language understanding and response generation, where the latter features a potentially unbounded response space, and a lack of objective

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

7

response generation, where the latter features a potentially unbounded response space, and a lack of objective success metrics, making it a highly challenging problem to model. Voice assistants such as Alexa and Google Assistant have significantly advanced the state of science for goal-directed conversations and successfully deployed these systems in production. However, the challenge of building agents which can carry multi-turn open-domain conversations is still far from being solved. To address these challenges and further the state of Conversational AI, Amazon launched a yearly competition called Alexa Prize in 2016. The grand challenge objective is to build agents that can converse coherently and engagingly with humans for 20 minutes, and obtain a 4 out of 5 or higher rating from humans

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

8

engagingly with humans for 20 minutes, and obtain a 4 out of 5 or higher rating from humans interacting with them. Apart from the Alexa Prize, there have been challenges like Dialog System Technology Challenge (DSTC) (Williams et al., 2016) (task based and closed domain) and Conversational AI Challenge (ConvAI) (Burtsev et al., 2018) (persona based, chit-chat and challenges with evaluation). Both of these challenges are text based as opposed to speech-based. Achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs in spoken form, which can be evaluated and measured for success, is the primary goal of the Alexa Prize. Through the Alexa Prize competition, participating universities have been able to conduct research and test

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

9

Prize. Through the Alexa Prize competition, participating universities have been able to conduct research and test hypotheses with real customer interactions by building socialbots, which are available to all Alexa users. Users interact with socialbots via the “Alexa, let’s chat” experience, engage in a live conversation, and can leave ratings and feedback for teams at the end of their conversations, which the teams can then use to continuously evaluate and improve their systems. The inaugural cohort consisted of 16 university teams that set the path for future research, did extensive experimentation and brought advancements across Natural Language Understanding (NLU), Knowledge Ingestion, Dialog Manager, Personalization, Response Generation and Selection (Ram et al., 2017). The

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

10

Knowledge Ingestion, Dialog Manager, Personalization, Response Generation and Selection (Ram et al., 2017). The winning team - Sounding Board (Fang et al., 2018) from the University of Washington achieved an average rating of 3.17 and an average conversation duration of 10 minutes and 22 seconds during the finals of the inaugural year of the competition. The 2018 cohort was made up of 8 teams, with 5 of them alumni of Alexa Prize 2017. 2018 teams not only expanded upon the learnings and research done in 2017 but also built several new components to handle compound sentences such as “I love watching the Harry Potter movies, but I think the books are more enjoyable” as well as contextual models for multi-turn dialogs. They

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

11

I think the books are more enjoyable” as well as contextual models for multi-turn dialogs. They also leveraged topic models and dialog acts for driving deep topical conversations and adapted their dialog manager based on user's interest. Teams also utilized extensive knowledge bases to enable broad coverage of topics and entities, and used a variety of linking techniques to transition between topics and entities within a knowledge graph. Based on the learnings from the 2017 competition, we provided several resources, models and tools to the university teams for 2018. To help teams focus more on science work and minimize effort spent on infrastructure for model hosting and scaling, we created CoBot, a conversational bot toolkit in Python for natural language understanding and

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

12

and scaling, we created CoBot, a conversational bot toolkit in Python for natural language understanding and dialog management. We also shared a variety of models such as Topic and Dialog Act Classifiers, Conversation Evaluators, and Sensitive Content Detector, which were broadly adopted by many teams. Furthermore, we drastically improved our Conversational Speech Recognition system, with a 25% relative improvement in Word Error Rate (WER) since the end of last year, to minimize errors in inputs to the socialbots. We also provided teams with weekly metrics reports computed from human annotations and statistical models to identify potential growth

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

13

3 areas for each. While there are a few datasets and challenges targeting improved dialogs and conversational AI, most of them are task oriented (e.g. DSTC Challenge) or targeted at more phatic or chatty interactions (e.g. ConvAI Challenge). The Alexa Prize is very different as it addresses many of the missing gaps pertaining to task-based datasets/challenges and chitchat or persona-based conversations. The conversations are spoken, not task-restricted, open-ended, topical, involve opinions, and are conducted with real users with continuous feedback. This enables the system to evolve over time, perform A/B tests and ingest learnings in real-time. Evaluation is completely subjective and the experience is rated by a

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

14

and ingest learnings in real-time. Evaluation is completely subjective and the experience is rated by a human in the loop. This data is extremely useful not only for improving existing systems such as conversational speech recognition and dialog act detection, but also for a variety of open research problems such as dialog evaluation, statistical dialog management, and sensitive content detection. In 2017, during the inaugural Alexa Prize participants performed a significant amount of research around a variety of models, primarily focused on natural language understanding, knowledge ingestion, dialog and context modeling, personalization, response generation and ranking and response selection. This work is described in more detail in the 1st Proceedings of the Alexa Prize. In this paper, we describe the scientific

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

15

detail in the 1st Proceedings of the Alexa Prize. In this paper, we describe the scientific and engineering advancements brought by the university teams and by Amazon to advance the state of Conversational AI during the 2018 competition. We also share the performance of socialbots across a variety of metrics including ratings, duration, coherence, engagement, and response quality. Finally, we address some of the open-ended problems in Conversational AI that we have made progress in this year, and share our learnings from the 2018 competition. 2 Alexa Prize Background Similar to the 2017 Alexa Prize, upon receiving a request to engage in a conversation with Alexa, e.g. “Alexa, Let's Chat”, Alexa customers were read a

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

16

conversation with Alexa, e.g. “Alexa, Let's Chat”, Alexa customers were read a brief message, then connected to one of the 8 participating socialbots. Customers were provided instructions on how to end the conversation and provide ratings and feedback. The introductory message and instructions changed through the competition to keep the information relevant to the different phrases. After exiting the conversation with the socialbot, which the user could do at any time, the user was prompted for a verbal rating: “How do you feel about speaking with this socialbot again?”, followed by an option to provide additional freeform feedback. Ratings and feedback were both shared back with the teams to help them improve their socialbots. The Alexa

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

17

and feedback were both shared back with the teams to help them improve their socialbots. The Alexa Prize 2018 was launched to a cohort of Amazon employees on April 10, followed by a public launch on May 16 at which time all US Alexa customers could interact with the participating socialbots. We followed a similar pattern to 2017 and followed this up with a semifinal phase that ran from July 2, 2018 - August 15, 2018 where customer ratings were used to determine finalists for Alexa Prize 2018. This was followed by a feedback phase for finalists, leading up to a closed door finals on Nov 6-7, 2018. Throughout the competition, the teams were required to maintain anonymity in their interactions to ensure fairness in

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

18

the competition, the teams were required to maintain anonymity in their interactions to ensure fairness in the competition. To drive maximum feedback to the teams and improve user engagement, the Alexa Prize experience was promoted through Echo customer emails, social media, blogs, and third-party publications. During each phase of the competition we drove at least one significant promotion, with two during the semifinals - one at the beginning and the other towards the end. Each of these promotions were carefully timed to bring the Alexa Prize to the top of customer’s attention, invite those unfamiliar to engage with the skill, and educate customers about the Prize. Especially as teams faced elimination at the end of semifinals, we

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

19

customers about the Prize. Especially as teams faced elimination at the end of semifinals, we strove to ensure teams had enough customer interactions to implement changes to their socialbots. This year, to drive further engagement we announced the three finalists via a live Twitch broadcast on August 30th. The event was promoted in advance and saw a wide variety of audience including academia, media, developers, and hobbyists alongside all the participating teams.

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

20

4 Over the course of the 2018 competition, we have driven over 60,000 hours of conversations spanning millions of interactions, 50% higher than we saw in the 2017 competition. 2.1 2018 Alexa Prize Finals The finals judging event was held in Seattle November 6-7, 2018. Each interaction involved 1 person talking to the socialbot and 3 people judging independently, determining the conversation stopping point based on coherence and engagement. An indication by a majority of the judges to end the interaction was counted as the end time for interaction. Conversations were rated by the judges on a scale from 1 to 5 stars, post indication of a need to end the conversation by a majority of the judges. The finals involved multiple

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

21

indication of a need to end the conversation by a majority of the judges. The finals involved multiple interactors, with each interactor having multiple conversations with each socialbot. During the finals, the teams demonstrated an improved ability to listen to what the user was saying, better entity disambiguation, and sustain more multi-turn interactions on a topic. They also demonstrated the need to develop improved capabilities for multi-intent parsing and management of dialog resulting from long, multi-intent inputs as well as the addition of more variability to their responses. 3 Engineering Advancements Through the Conversational Bot Toolkit (CoBot) 3.1 Background During the 2017 Alexa Prize, each of the competing teams built their own unique conversational

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

22

Background During the 2017 Alexa Prize, each of the competing teams built their own unique conversational agents. In our examination of each team's work, we identified common successful strategies, as well as common pitfalls, for the purpose of providing competitors in the 2018 Alexa Prize a starting point from which to build more sophisticated agents. To help teams focus more on advancing the state of science in Conversational AI and minimize effort spent on infrastructure hosting and scaling, we created CoBot, a conversational bot toolkit in Python for natural language understanding and dialog management. The toolkit provides a set of tools, libraries and base models designed to help develop, train and deploy open-domain or multi-domain conversational experiences through the Alexa

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

23

designed to help develop, train and deploy open-domain or multi-domain conversational experiences through the Alexa Skills Kit (ASK). The primary goal of CoBot is to drive improved quality of conversational agents by providing a toolkit that is modular, extensible, and scalable, and provide abstractions for infrastructure and low-level tasks. CoBot provides a continuous integration pipeline where experimentation in language understanding, dialog management techniques, and response generation strategies can be integrated and tested by a single command. This enables seamless scaling from development and test to production workloads on AWS. CoBot uses many of the same principles found in the Node.JS, Python, and Java SDKs of the Alexa Skills Kit or ASK (Kumar et

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

24

the Node.JS, Python, and Java SDKs of the Alexa Skills Kit or ASK (Kumar et al., 2017), as well as general dialog toolkits like Rasa (Bocklisch et al., 2017) and DeepPavlov (Burtsev et al., 2017). CoBot exposes generalized dialog management, state tracking, and Natural Language Understanding (NLU) capabilities that are modular in nature. Unlike other toolkits, CoBot places an emphasis on infrastructure to host models and handle massive scale at runtime. While sharing key elements with the above-referenced Alexa SDKs, CoBot focuses on open-domain or multi-domain conversational experiences, with an emphasis on integration of pre-trained and university-developed deep learning models. 3.2 Impact As a result of CoBot use, new

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

25

and university-developed deep learning models. 3.2 Impact As a result of CoBot use, new Alexa Prize 2018 teams were able to build basic socialbots in significantly reduced timeline (weeks in 2018 vs. months in 2017), and drastically cut engineering overhead from scaling efforts (<2 days to address load testing failures in 2018 vs. 1-2 weeks in 2017). Students and faculty of CoBot-based teams became active participants in the development process, not only driving our engineering efforts through feature requests, but also contributing code for enhancements or bug fixes.

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

26

5 3.3 Design Philosophy We engineered CoBot to be flexible, stateful, and scalable, while providing means of fast iteration, end-to-end software testing and experimentation through continuous integration and continuous deployment. Following are several key characteristics of CoBot: • Flexible: The CoBot toolkit allows the user to mix and match Natural Language Understanding(NLU), Natural Language Generation(NLG), and dialog strategies. Default CoBot implementations of these strategies are easily overridden, A/B test support is built-in. Because CoBot is non-opinionated, users are in control of NLU, selection strategies, ranking strategies, and the deep learning frameworks used to train models. • Stateful: Coherent multi-turn conversations are difficult to achieve without

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

27

frameworks used to train models. • Stateful: Coherent multi-turn conversations are difficult to achieve without the use of context. CoBot’s state management stores the current state and state history of a conversation in AWS DynamoDB, a very fast key-value datastore. At a base level, the state is defined as the current user utterance, potential agent responses and any additional NLU attributes that were collected during a current turn in the conversation. The CoBot model of state management ensures low latency, along with consistent and reliable data access. It is flexible, allowing the user to store and retrieve any additional key-value pairs they want within the state. • Scalable: During the 2017 Alexa Prize Amazon customers engaged in millions

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

28

within the state. • Scalable: During the 2017 Alexa Prize Amazon customers engaged in millions of conversations with socialbots, with large variability based on season, time of day and day of week, and occasional large spikes around marketing events. To efficiently handle this level of traffic in 2018, CoBot utilizes AWS Lambda, a serverless compute platform, and deploys large machine-learned models in Amazon Elastic Container Service (ECS). CoBot can be extended by making use of local modules (for light weight models) and remote modules (for large machine-learned models, whether team-developed or pre-trained libraries such as Spacy). CoBot can also take advantage of models hosted on AWS SageMaker, a fully-managed model training and inference service.

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

29

Figure 1 CoBot System Diagram and Workflow 3.4 Testing and Experimentation CoBot provides several mechanisms with which to test code or evaluate feature additions. Local end-to-end testing launches local Docker containers to test modules. The CoBot CLI can be used to simulate conversations by ingesting a text file of sample utterances, or allowing the developer to provide interactive input through the keyboard. Through the local testing, developers can iterate on code in a local development environment, before committing their changes to their Beta or Prod environments. CoBot contains robust logging, configurable with standard Python logging levels. Logs are stored in Amazon CloudWatch, a monitoring and management service, and can be used to diagnose and debug errors. Using the CoBot CLI’s transcribe feature, a user can easily view the transcription of a conversation between the socialbot and a user.

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

30

6 CoBot allows experimentation by offering the ability to run A/B tests on alternately configured entry points (also called handlers). Users reaching one entry point may receive a different set of components, responses, or pipeline features than users reaching a separately configured entry point. The detailed architecture can be seen in Figure 2. Figure 2 CoBot Architecture Since feedback on Alexa Prize conversations is provided partly in the form of a numeric score, CoBot developers are able to experiment with A/B testing to provide insight to which features and scientific approaches yield the best results. 3.5 Toolkit and Data Services CoBot provides seamless integration to the Alexa Prize Toolkit Service, which host several deep neural

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

31

CoBot provides seamless integration to the Alexa Prize Toolkit Service, which host several deep neural network models for common conversational Natural Language Processing (NLP) tasks. This alleviates the need for developers to recreate these common models. We have included models for Topic Classification, Dialog Act Classification, Sensitive Content Detection, Question Answering and Conversation Evaluation as part of the Toolkit Service. Because the CoBot Toolkit leverages persistent storage of data and an underlying infrastructure on AWS, we are also able to provide rich data analysis services, like data querying and visualization. Turn-based conversational and state data are persisted to DynamoDB tables. Amazon S3 buckets are used to store daily ratings and feedback data, as well as weekly

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

32

tables. Amazon S3 buckets are used to store daily ratings and feedback data, as well as weekly coherence and engagement data, which are correlated to conversational data in DynamoDB. CoBot makes it easy to use Amazon Athena to query and analyze data directly in Amazon S3 using standard SQL commands. In addition to this, Amazon QuickSight can be used to visualize this data and create live dashboards. The ability to query and visualize real-time data makes it easy for CoBot developers to make informed and prompt decisions based on data rather than hunches. 4 Scientific Advancements The Alexa Prize fosters an environment that encourages a diverse set of experimental approaches to building open domain conversational agents or socialbots. The Alexa

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

33

a diverse set of experimental approaches to building open domain conversational agents or socialbots. The Alexa Prize participants this year have explored novel ideas in the areas of natural language understanding, dialog management, error correction, and personalization. We highlight below some of the approaches taken by Alexa Prize teams this year in these areas. For a more in depth explanation, we refer readers to the individual team papers.

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

34

7 4.1 From The Alexa Prize Participants 4.1.1 Handling Automatic Speech recognition (ASR) Errors While performance of automatic speech recognition (ASR) has significantly improved in real-world far-field use cases such as on Alexa-enabled devices, it is still a challenging problem to achieve high accuracy across a wide array environmental conditions and for open-domain dialog systems where the user can discuss any topic and mention a huge number of unique named entities. As such, error rates tend to be higher during user dialog with Alexa Prize socialbots, and it is important for teams to be able to handle ASR errors before sending it to their socialbots for downstream tasks such as NLU processing. Iris (Ahmadvand et

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

35

sending it to their socialbots for downstream tasks such as NLU processing. Iris (Ahmadvand et al., 2018) and Slugbot (Bowden et al., 2018) took a standard approach of having a threshold on word level and sentence level confidence scores. If the confidence was too low, the socialbot was prompted to ask the user to clarify what he/she said. However, if the socialbot prompts for clarification too many times this leads to a high friction experience for the user. Additionally, several teams retain n-best hypothesis for their response modules to counteract any noise in the input. Alquist took the approach of first applying case restoration techniques on ASR results before sending it to downstream applications such as NER.

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

36

applying case restoration techniques on ASR results before sending it to downstream applications such as NER. Gunrock (Chen et al., 2018) took a unique approach by creating an ASR Correction module that captured homophones by leveraging a contextual knowledge base. When the word level confidence score was below a certain threshold, the socialbot would query the knowledge base for the domain of the current conversation to retrieve substitute noun phrases in the user utterance using relevant meta-phonetic (homophone) information. 4.1.2 Response Modules, Ranking Strategies and Natural Language Generation In order to deal with the vast number of possible utterances coming into a socialbot, many teams used multiple response modules where each response module would be responsible for a

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

37

coming into a socialbot, many teams used multiple response modules where each response module would be responsible for a particular domain or set of domains. For example, one response module may handle Q/A, giving facts/news along with modules trained to respond to certain topics such as movies, music or sports. These response modules used rule-based, retrieval-based or generative techniques to produce responses. Teams used open sourced datasets or APIs for their response modules such as Reddit, News API, EVI, Wikidata, IMDB, ESPN, Washington Post, DuckDuckGo, Rotten Tomatoes, Spotify, and Bing. For rule-based bots, teams used ELIZA (Weizenbaum et al., 1966) and relied on AIML to handcraft responses. For retrieval-based methods,

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

38

et al., 1966) and relied on AIML to handcraft responses. For retrieval-based methods, Alana scraped popular subreddits such as “ShowerThoughts" and “Today I Learned" and indexed them using Lucene. They then could execute a retrieval-based match for noun phrases mentioned in the user’s utterance. After generating a set of candidate responses from response modules, socialbots need to select the best response. In order to try to avoid generic and incoherent responses, Alana (Curry et al., 2018) built bot-specific classifiers using the dialogue context. Alana manually annotated responses as appropriate, inappropriate or potentially appropriate to train their model. Iris (Ahmadvand et al., 2018) selected responses for their news bot by ranking

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

39

train their model. Iris (Ahmadvand et al., 2018) selected responses for their news bot by ranking results based on how far the words in the user utterance are from the start of a news article and based on the user's preferred news domains. Eve (Fulda et al., 2018) focused more broadly on trying to identify the subset of possible responses first before narrowing down on a single response. Their method revolves around embedding conversational history into an embedding vector along with candidate responses into an embedding vector. They then looked for a candidate utterance, and shifted their conversational history embedding in that direction to match the resulting flow. SlugBot and Eve, used rankers which had hand engineered features, based on items such as

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

40

flow. SlugBot and Eve, used rankers which had hand engineered features, based on items such as confidence score from a response generator, length of an utterance, whether an utterance has already been repeated or not and if an utterance was deemed coherent. Most teams used template based modules for rendering responses. Gunrock tried to avoid duplicate responses by creating many surface forms for each template and picking one at random. They also

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

41

8 tried to create dynamic templates where specific slots can be swapped out. These methods, while resulting in generally coherent responses, still represent bounded simulations of the variety found in human-human conversation. 4.1.3 Knowledge Graphs Representing knowledge and ingesting that knowledge in open domain conversation is a challenging problem but it is necessary in order to have multi-turn topical conversations. Many teams relied on representing knowledge in graph databases, with AWS Neptune serving as a popular choice. Iris, Slugbot, and Gunrock used knowledge bases storing millions of different topics and entities. They leveraged open data sources such as DBPedia, Wikidata, Reddit, Twitter and IMDB. Fantom (Jonell et al., 2018)

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

42

such as DBPedia, Wikidata, Reddit, Twitter and IMDB. Fantom (Jonell et al., 2018) tried to take the idea further and turned their knowledge graph into a dialog structure. The graph contains nodes representing an utterance, either from the socialbot or from the user. An edge between node X to node Y means that utterance Y is an appropriate answer to utterance X. A path through the graph thus represents a dialog between user and the socialbot. For knowledge ingestion, Alana (Curry et al., 2018) developed a system called the Contextualized Linked Concept Generator. When an entity is mentioned, they search for interesting entities within their graph using different linking strategies. Once a plausible entity in the same domain is found they

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

43

within their graph using different linking strategies. Once a plausible entity in the same domain is found they will leverage the links used to find additional entities to generate a full response. 4.1.4 Dialogue Management A key component of socialbots is to be able to manage dialog effectively. Many teams leveraged contextual information in their dialog management systems. This contextual information came from NLP pipelines that will be discussed in Section 4.1.7. Many of these systems are still intent/slot based but have been extended to handle other features such as topic, sentiment, and dialog act. Alquist (Pichl et al., 2018) experimented with statistical dialogue management systems, utilizing hybrid code networks (HCN) (Williams et al., 2017)

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

44

with statistical dialogue management systems, utilizing hybrid code networks (HCN) (Williams et al., 2017) modified for the open domain use case, by taking in as input the conversational context, along with dialogue acts and system actions, and outputted either text responses or functions. Text responses are directly returned as the response while functions are represented as a reference to code which needs to be executed. 4.1.5 Sensitive Content Detection Sensitive Content includes items such as offensive, abusive or hateful content. However, there are a broad set of utterances that do not have obvious profanity or hateful content but may be deemed sensitive due to recent events or deep knowledge of cultural context. To tackle sensitive content detection, teams such as Slugbot, Iris

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

45

or deep knowledge of cultural context. To tackle sensitive content detection, teams such as Slugbot, Iris and Fantom took the standard approach by using a profanity checker before returning responses from bots. Eve (Fulda et al., 2018) tried to create sensitive detection models that utilizes context. Eve started with a blacklist of offensive words and divided it into categories of: 1) blatantly offensive words, 2) words that occur frequently in the context of offensive language 3) and words that may be offensive to an individual user which the bot only would talk about based on a user's permission. The Alexa Prize provided a sensitive content classifier (described in Section 4.2.3) through the Cobot toolkit, which several teams utilized in their

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

46

(described in Section 4.2.3) through the Cobot toolkit, which several teams utilized in their pipeline. Alana and Tartan trained their own model to detect abusive content. Tartan (Larionov et al., 2018) trained a supervised model on Reddit data using the “controversial” score given for each user message as their signal. Alana trained a model on Alexa Prize data which they annotated themselves and once abuse towards their bot was detected, they would try to drive the conversation in a different direction to mitigate further offensive content.

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

47

9 4.1.6 Customer Experience and Personalization Iris (Ahmadvand et al., 2018) took the approach of creating a personalized topic model to predict which topic a customer would be interested in discussing next. They trained and tested a Conditional Random Field (CRF)-based sequence model on specific groups of customers: returning customers, new customers and customers split by time zones. From their experiments, they found this model has higher accuracy as compared to purely suggesting random popular topics to users. Eve tried to create a personal experience by measuring users mood through sentiment analysis. This would then be used downstream to up-vote certain response generators they believe would respond well to a certain user personality. Alana built systems to make the

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

48

generators they believe would respond well to a certain user personality. Alana built systems to make the customer feel more welcomed. Because the conversations in Alexa Prize are highly topical there will be entities mentioned by the socialbot that a user may not have heard of. Alana implemented an entity explanation mechanism which provides domain specific information associated with a given entity, extracted from the Wikidata (Vrandečić et al., 2014) knowledge base. 4.1.7 Natural Language Understanding(NLU) for Open Domain Dialog After a user has initiated a conversation, a socialbot requires a robust Natural Language Understanding (NLU) system to identify various semantic elements of a user utterance. This includes but is not limited to intent, dialog act,

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

49

semantic elements of a user utterance. This includes but is not limited to intent, dialog act, topic, named entities and user sentiment (Allen 1995). NLU is a difficult problem in the open domain setting because of the ambiguity and uncertainty in conversational speech. Teams described innovative approaches in areas of conversation NLU, as summarized below. Intent and Dialog Act Detection: Intents represent the goal of a user for a given utterance. A dialog system needs to detect intents well to respond appropriately to that utterance. In addition to this, a conversation can be broken down and represented as a series of dialog acts that are but not limited to question, request for information, or delivery of information. Iris, Gunrock and Alquist

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

50

but not limited to question, request for information, or delivery of information. Iris, Gunrock and Alquist used supervised methods to train classification models for predicting intents and dialog acts. Slugbot used the CAPC dataset provided by Alexa Prize to train their intent models. Named Entity Recognition (NER) and Noun Phrase (NP) extraction: Recognizing named entities (e.g. person, organization, etc.) in an utterance is an important step to understanding a user’s intent. Alquist trained custom NER models using manually labeled utterances gathered during conversations with real users. Iris and Fantom used a large database to recognize relevant entities in a user's utterance. Iris also trained an entity classifier, using DBpedia (Auer et al.,

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

51

in a user's utterance. Iris also trained an entity classifier, using DBpedia (Auer et al., 2007) entities as their dataset and a convolutional neural network. Anaphora and Co-reference Resolution: Multi-turn dialog systems need to resolve ambiguous phrases with reference to prior entities for downstream tasks such as response generation. Fantom, Tartan and Slugbot did co-reference resolution by using open source tools such as SpaCy, Stanford CoreNLP, and NeuralCoref (2017). Gunrock noted that these state-of-the-art models are not adapted to conversational data and tried to build their own coreference resolution models using NER outputs. Alana performed ellipsis resolution by transforming a user utterance using contextual information, for example transforming "Yes"

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

52

performed ellipsis resolution by transforming a user utterance using contextual information, for example transforming "Yes" to "Yes I do like tea" such that their models can respond with much more detail. Topic Detection: Because Alexa Prize conversations center around topics, it is crucial to predict topics of user utterances to lead to more coherent and engaging responses. Tartan, Slugbot, Fantom, Eve and Gunrock used the Cobot Topic Classifier as described in Section 4.2.2. Gunrock and Alana used knowledge graphs such as Google Knowledge graph and Microsoft Concept Graph to detect topics from named entities. Iris (Ahmadvand et al., 2018) introduced a contextual topic classifier into their system. Sentence Segmentation: In natural conversation, users

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

53

2018) introduced a contextual topic classifier into their system. Sentence Segmentation: In natural conversation, users often express multiple thoughts in a single complex statement. Without post-processing on ASR outputs, NLU systems may face difficulty classifying these statements. Gunrock (Chen et al., 2018) trained a sentence segmentation module

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

54

10 to break a user's utterance into to smaller segments to be able to capture the semantic meaning, and utilized start and end times of words in ASR hypotheses provided by Amazon as features to help train their model. Sentiment: To better understand a user's mood, teams used sentiment detection methods. Some teams used open source tools such as VADER(Gilbert et al., 2014). Alquist trained a bidirectional recurrent (GRU) neural network on movie review data, generalizing to other conversational inputs. 4.2 Science Advancements from the Alexa Prize Team 4.2.1 Automatic Speech Recognition Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR), a system which converts spoken words to text, is the first component a user interacts with in

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

55

a system which converts spoken words to text, is the first component a user interacts with in a spoken dialog system. It is crucial to recognize a user utterance as accurately as possible, as this will impact all of the downstream systems. Entity Error Rate Due to the highly topical nature of the Alexa Prize conversations, it is important to capture entities in user utterances which can then be used by the socialbots to return responses. In addition to measuring Word Error Rate(WER), we also actively measure Entity Error Rate(EER). Each word in a user utterance is annotated with a topic. For a particular topic say “Entertainment_Music” the number of substitution and deletion errors are counted. This metric roughly captures how

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

56

the number of substitution and deletion errors are counted. This metric roughly captures how well we are recognizing named entities. A key technique for reducing EER is moving to contextual ASR systems. We will present work we have done in this area taking a non-neural and neural approach for language modeling. Contextual Language Model Adaptation ASR systems traditionally consist of an acoustic model, a pronunciation model, and a statistical language model. Traditionally the role of the statistical language model is used to resolve ambiguities, regardless of context. We can improve the accuracy of the system by leveraging contextual information. For example, if language model has to determine the probability of the next word in the utterance “Alexa,

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

57

if language model has to determine the probability of the next word in the utterance “Alexa, I love … ”. The probabilities of the next word being “The Godfather” or “The Beatles” would be very different if the user’s recent interactions with Alexa were about movies or music. We took two approaches to this problem – first, we added contextual information to a dynamic interpolation framework. In work we previously reported (Raju and Hedayatnia et al., 2018), we describe a machine-learning system that mixes different statistical language models based on contextual information. The method can leverage any type of contextual information, but in particular can examine the history a user’s interactions with a socialbot system. More specifically

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

58

but in particular can examine the history a user’s interactions with a socialbot system. More specifically we dynamically mix together various n-gram based language models. This is done by changing the interpolation weights for our n-gram based LM at each turn to better adapt and recognize a user utterance. We predict these interpolation weights using a Deep Neural Network that is trained to maximize the log-likelihood of the training data. We reported relative Word Error Rate (WER) reductions up to 6%. For Entity Error Rate (EER), we reduced errors by 10-15%. The EER metric is particularly important because recognizing named entities is crucial for socialbot systems. The complete list of results can be found in our results section. We have also explored neural

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

59

The complete list of results can be found in our results section. We have also explored neural methods to incorporate context, involving adding contextual information for Recurrent Neural Network (RNN) models in a rescoring framework. In work presented in (Mehri et al.), we explore various methods to effectively encode conversational context into a Neural Language Model (NLM), specifically an LSTM-RNN model. Our contextual information primarily consists of the history of a user's interactions with a socialbot system. Additionally we look at integrating linguistic features such as sentence topic derived from the context. The models used to generate these derived features allow us to leverage external data sources for training. We explore various architectures on how to best incorporate

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

60

to leverage external data sources for training. We explore various architectures on how to best incorporate this contextual information and in particular, deal with differences between socialbot responses and user utterances.

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

61

11 We obtained a 6.4% Word Error Rate (WER) reduction and a 7.2% Entity Error Rate (EER) reduction over a non-contextual NLM. The full results are shown in Table 4. 4.2.2 Contextual Topic and Dialog Act Models Identifying topics (such as Sports or Politics) and corresponding keywords from an utterance within a conversation helps in retrieving or generating the right set of information requested by the user. Dialog acts such as “greeting”, “question”, “opinion request”, etc. are useful as general intents in the context of conversations, which guide the flow of the conversation. When combined, these are valuable features for open domain natural language understanding. One of the challenges with topic,

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

62

combined, these are valuable features for open domain natural language understanding. One of the challenges with topic, keyword and dialog act detection in open-domain conversations is effectively integrating context. In human-human or human-bot interactions, it is possible that the topic in the current utterance is a function of utterances or responses in prior turns. To help university teams building better socialbots in 2018, we built context-aware topic and dialog act classification models. We obtained annotations for 10,000 Alexa Prize conversations with over 120,000 utterances, labeled across 12 topics (Politics, Fashion, Sports, Science and Technology, Entertainment [Music, Movies, Books, General], Phatic, Other, Interactive, Inappropriate Content) and 14 dialog acts (Information [Request,

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

63

Books, General], Phatic, Other, Interactive, Inappropriate Content) and 14 dialog acts (Information [Request, Delivery], Opinion [Request, Expression], General Chat, Clarification, Topic Switch, User Instruction, Instruction Response, Interactive, Other, Multiple Goals, Frustration Expression, Not Set). We also obtained word level annotations to obtain the topic of each word within an utterance. We trained Deep Average Network and BiLSTM based contextual models. These models are described in more detail along with some example annotations at (Khatri et al., 2018a). 4.2.3 Sensitive Content Detection Classifier In an open-domain dialog setting, one of the hardest tasks to address is detecting sensitive or offensive content. Sensitive content includes racism, profanity, hate speech, violence, sexual content

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

64

detecting sensitive or offensive content. Sensitive content includes racism, profanity, hate speech, violence, sexual content or any kind of inappropriate content which may be offensive to people based on gender, demographic factors, culture or religion. There are many challenging aspects of this problem, such as coverage (a blacklist of words may not capture all kinds of sensitive content), cultural differences (sensitive content for one culture may not be sensitive for other), context (when viewed as a single utterance might seem perfectly innocuous but when viewed within a wider context they become offensive), sarcasm, non-standard vocabulary, factual correctness and recency of the content. Most of the teams retrieve information and train models for their socialbots from publicly available data sources such as

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

65

of the teams retrieve information and train models for their socialbots from publicly available data sources such as Reddit and Twitter, which are well-known to contain significant amounts of offensive materials. No large-scale labeled data set for training exists that addresses all the types of sensitive content described above. To address this challenge, we generated training data from common internet forum conversations using a two-stage semi-supervised approach, which is illustrated in Figure 3. Figure 3 Two Stage Semi-Supervision for Sensitive Content Detection

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

66

12 Stage 1 consists of sorting these topical forums with our blacklist by simply counting the number of words in said blacklist. Our blacklist corresponds to a manually curated list of approximately 800 offensive words. During Stage 2, high confidence sensitive comments and non-sensitive comments were sampled using a weakly supervised classifier trained on the Toxic Wikipedia Comments dataset (Jigsaw, 2018). Overall, we sampled 10 Million comments each for our sensitive and non-sensitive classes, which were then used to train a BiLSTM classifier in which word representations were initialized using GLoVE (Pennington et al., 2014) embeddings and then fine-tuned during training. More information about the model can be obtained at (Khatri et al., 2018b). Results of using this model can be

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

67

the model can be obtained at (Khatri et al., 2018b). Results of using this model can be found in Section 5.1.3. 4.2.4 Contextual Conversational Evaluators Evaluation of dialogue systems is a challenging research problem, which despite being studied lacks a widely-agreed-upon metric. There is significant previous work on evaluating goal oriented dialogue systems such as TRAINS system (Ferguson et al., 1996), PARADISE (Walker et al., 1997), SASSI (Hone and Graham, 2000) and MIMIC (ChuCarroll, 2000), which are easier to evaluate than open-ended, non-goal oriented systems, because we can measure systems by successful completion of tasks. Venkatesh et al., 2017 describes limitations in the Turing Test

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

68

by successful completion of tasks. Venkatesh et al., 2017 describes limitations in the Turing Test (Turing 1950) model, due to divergences in information availability, objective misalignment and incentive to produce plausible but low-information content responses. One of the primary ways in which quality of socialbots is evaluated through Alexa Prize is through user ratings. We ask Alexa users to rate the conversation on the scale of 1 to 5 based on how much they would like to speak with the socialbot again. These ratings don't provide immediate feedback during the interaction and they don't provide information about turn-level quality. To address this challenge, we defined the following five metrics for evaluating turn-level performance of open-domain dialog systems: 1.

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

69

we defined the following five metrics for evaluating turn-level performance of open-domain dialog systems: 1. Comprehensible: The information provided by the socialbot made sense with respect to the user utterance. 2. On-topic or Relevant: The socialbot response was on the same topic as the user utterance or was relevant to the user utterance. For example, if a user asks about a baseball player on Boston Red Sox, then the socialbot should mention the correct baseball team. 3. Response Incorrectness: The socialbot response is irrelevant or inappropriate. In a highly subjective task, it is hard to evaluate the correctness of the response. Evaluating if the response is irrelevant or inappropriate, however, is relatively easy. 4. Interesting: The socialbot response contains information

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

70

irrelevant or inappropriate, however, is relatively easy. 4. Interesting: The socialbot response contains information which is novel and relevant. For example, the socialbot would provide an answer about a baseball player and provide some additional information to create a fleshed out response. 5. Continue Conversation: Given the current state of the conversation and the system response, there is a natural way to continue the conversation. For example, this could be due to the socialbot asking a question to the user about the current conversation subject. Around 15,000 Alexa Prize conversations containing 160,000 utterances were annotated by humans on the five metrics described above. We provided definitions and examples to the annotators and trained them to annotate Alexa Prize conversations. We

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

71

provided definitions and examples to the annotators and trained them to annotate Alexa Prize conversations. We asked them to annotate each response given the utterance and context (past turns) on how coherent and engaging the response is. They were asked to read the conversation starting from the first turn and then assign either “yes” or “no” corresponding to each metric (“is comprehensible”, “is on-topic”, “is incorrect”, etc.) for each turn. At turn number “n”, they had access to entire context in the past “n-1” turns, i.e. past utterances and responses to evaluate the response given the context.

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

72

13 Figure 4 Contextual Conversation Evaluators Figure 4 depicts the model we trained corresponding to the five proposed metrics for dialog evaluation. We used several features, including context and entity-grids, to train these models. More information about the model can be obtained at (Yi et al., 2018). These models can be integrated into several dialog system components, including statistical dialog managers. More information on the metrics used in the conversation evaluators can be found in Section 5.1.4. 5 Results In Section 4.2, we described several models we built and shared with the university teams for use in the Alexa Prize competition. In this section, we first provide the performance of various models that were

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

73

the Alexa Prize competition. In this section, we first provide the performance of various models that were shared with the teams and then showcase the improvement in quality of socialbots over the course of the competition on various metrics. 5.1 Alexa Prize Models 5.1.1 Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) In Figure 5 we can see the relative Word Error Rate (WER) and Entity Error Rate (EER) improvement since the start of the 2018 Alexa Prize with respect to the final 2017 Alexa Prize baseline. In our currently deployed model, the WER and EER are 30% and 26% lower than at the Figure 5 Relative Word Error Rate and Entity Error Rate relative to the end of Alexa

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

74

Figure 5 Relative Word Error Rate and Entity Error Rate relative to the end of Alexa Prize 2017 end of the 2017 Alexa Prize (and 55% and 34% lower, respectively, than at the start of the program). Significant improvement in ASR quality have been obtained by ingesting the Alexa Prize 0102030405060708090100

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

75

Baseline2345Relative Error Rate2018 Alexa Prize ASR Model VersionsConversational ASR Relative WER/EER WERREERR

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

76

14 conversation transcriptions in the models and by the Language Model advancements described in this paper. Contextual Language Model Adaptation We utilized two methods for contextually biasing language models – first was an n-gram based method, the results of which are described in Table 3. As described in Section 4.2.1, we bias the language model using contextual information in the form of past user utterances and TTS responses, adapting the interpolation weights of an n-gram language model at each user turn. These interpolation weights are outputted by a deep neural network (DNN) which takes in as input the contextual information. Cross-Entropy (XENT) and perplexity (PPL) refer to alternate loss functions that were used to train the DNN model. We refer the reader to (Raju and Hedayatnia et al., 2018) for more details on these models.

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

77

Table 3 Contextual ASR results We also experimented with a neural approach to bias RNN language models, as described in Table 4. More detail on this method can be found in (Mehri et al.). “Avg Embed” and “Diff LSTM Enc” refer to methods to encode TTS responses into our model. For the first method, we average word embeddings for TTS responses and concatenate them at every time-step of our RNN model. For the second, we use a separate RNN encoder to encode our TTS responses into a hidden state vector which is used to initialize the hidden state of our decoder model. Table 4 Relative WER and EER using RNN Language Models w.r.t Context Free Baseline

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

78

Table 4 Relative WER and EER using RNN Language Models w.r.t Context Free Baseline 5.1.2 Topic and Dialog Act Models Based on our experiments, a bidirectional LSTM-based (BiLSTM) contextual dialog act model performs significantly better than the equivalent non-contextual model. The baseline model obtains an accuracy of 50% while adding parts of speech, context and topical features (obtained using DAN based semi-supervised topic model (Guo et al., 2017) leads to an improved accuracy of 71%. Similarly, a BiLSTM contextual topic model outperforms the non-contextual BiLSTM, Deep Average Network(DAN) and Attention Deep Average Network(ADAN) models. We obtained an accuracy of 76% for our best setting when compared

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

79

Deep Average Network(ADAN) models. We obtained an accuracy of 76% for our best setting when compared to 55% obtained through our baseline model. ModelsRelative Word Error Rate (WER)Relative Entity Error Rate (EER)Context Free Baseline-- Average Embed + Prepend-4.70%-5.90%Different LSTM Encoder + Derived-6.10%-7.20%Average Embed + Derived-6.40%-7.20%

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

80

15 We have observed that these tasks are difficult for manual annotation because of the subjective nature of the problem – Table 5 provides more detailed information on inter-annotator agreement. The accuracy of the contextual dialog act (70%) and topic models (76%) is higher than the percentage of times annotation matches by all three annotators. In fact, the contextual dialog act model's accuracy is also higher than the case where at least two annotators provide the same annotation, which implies that the model has learned to generalize well on this subjective task and correct for variation in individual annotators. For the keyword detection task, we observed that a supervised model outperforms unsupervised attention-based models (Guo et al., 2017). The contextual BiLSTM model performs better than ADAN on precision and recall of keyword detection as described in Table 6. In future work, we will explore the performance of models with explicit anaphora and co-reference resolution features. Most Alexa Prize teams used the topic, keyword and dialog act models to improve the quality of their socialbots. Table 5 Inter-annotator agreement

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227

1812.10757

81

Table 6 Keyword detection metrics. 5.1.3 Sensitive Content Detection Classifier The models trained using two-stage semi-supervision (TS Bootstrap) as described in Section 4.2.3 outperform supervised models trained on the Alexa Prize annotated test-set and on the following publicly available dataset: Toxic Wikipedia Comment data (TX). On the Alexa Prize test set (sample size: 6000 utterances), the TS Bootstrap model scored an Accuracy and F1-score of 96% and 95.5% respectively as compared to supervised models trained on annotated Toxic data, which scored 85% and 75% respectively. We note that the model trained using large scale two-stage semi-supervision generalizes well across a variety of unseen datasets such as Twitter. Results of our Sensitive model are shown in Table 7. It can be observed that our large scale semi-supervised techniques (Bootstrap and TS Bootstrap) are

1812.10757

Advancing the State of the Art in Open Domain Dialog Systems through the Alexa Prize

Building open domain conversational systems that allow users to have engaging conversations on topics of their choice is a challenging task. Alexa Prize was launched in 2016 to tackle the problem of achieving natural, sustained, coherent and engaging open-domain dialogs. In the second iteration of the competition in 2018, university teams advanced the state of the art by using context in dialog models, leveraging knowledge graphs for language understanding, handling complex utterances, building statistical and hierarchical dialog managers, and leveraging model-driven signals from user responses. The 2018 competition also included the provision of a suite of tools and models to the competitors including the CoBot (conversational bot) toolkit, topic and dialog act detection models, conversation evaluators, and a sensitive content detection model so that the competing teams could focus on building knowledge-rich, coherent and engaging multi-turn dialog systems. This paper outlines the advances developed by the university teams as well as the Alexa Prize team to achieve the common goal of advancing the science of Conversational AI. We address several key open-ended problems such as conversational speech recognition, open domain natural language understanding, commonsense reasoning, statistical dialog management, and dialog evaluation. These collaborative efforts have driven improved experiences by Alexa users to an average rating of 3.61, the median duration of 2 mins 18 seconds, and average turns to 14.6, increases of 14%, 92%, 54% respectively since the launch of the 2018 competition. For conversational speech recognition, we have improved our relative Word Error Rate by 55% and our relative Entity Error Rate by 34% since the launch of the Alexa Prize. Socialbots improved in quality significantly more rapidly in 2018, in part due to the release of the CoBot toolkit.

http://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.10757

2018 Alexa Prize Proceedings

cs.CL

20181227

20181227