Datasets:

janaab

/

supreme-court-speech

like 1

narvekar was proved

so far as they attempted to state something in the nature of a test

para fifty

all my lords have got one hundred and five one

it is only a contract which should be the arbitration agreement which is contemplated in section eleven six a of the act

in one case it is exploration and the other case it is rectification of the damage caused to the area affected by mining or the people

my lord what happens is let me clarify that position

in essence it's also a statutory contract

he can say that

this has nothing to do with pakistan or india

'the high court has held that the word liquor ordinarily means a strong drink as opposed to soft drink but it must in any event be a beverage which is ordinarily drunk

that is no problem

coelho and i've put here actually what the question was and the facts to allow us to actually understand what was decided 'the matter was duly referred to a bench of nine judges

because parliament converted said that we declare the legislature of the state of jammu and kashmir as a constituent assembly

that condition

we know that

see in a matter this becomes too complex to get into

it is said it is no longer on isolated pools

yes

that was an individual case

so different headings were given to them

my lord our concern is apart is

one is the domicile requirement

mr

yes asian resurfacing

the first of january nineteen thirty nine

it was amended thereafter in twenty seventeen

yes

on the one hand you say if it's established by statute then you have not established it and this is a far reaching consequences and then ugc act specifically says you must do it by statute and by no other method

you can sit down

your lordship

in fact the real rate of taxation went up to one hundred and three percent

so whereas the state is suffering from the loss of tax the other side will be burdened with heavy taxation

it helps trade and commerce

seven i'll read

then my lords the notices

the nodal counsel shall ensure that the convenience compilations are indexed and paginated to facilitate the hearing

hg mudgal's case then b my lords mr

are you entitled to be in the room or not the president decides

the parallel of this entry in the union list because for tax purpose it seems framers divided this thing

if the union traces it to entry fifty two then obviously for that reason also entry ninety seven cannot be used because then it falls in entry twenty four

that's why the agriculturalist has been excluded

except that prima facie came in twenty nineteen so parliament had before it

my lord the concern would be that you register a criminal case and ask sbi that give me the details

now just to give a background these petitions relate to temporary provisions which were brought in during world war two nineteen thirty nine

yes

now there are observation that thirty one c also this will apply in coelho itself

yes

i want your lordship to notice one thing at the outset that section eleven has a marginal note for appointment of arbitrators

how

so i've taken the liberty my lord in my written submission of itemizing what draws from the two reference orders

'the rates of stamp duty in respect of bills of exchange checks so and so'

he is the president

that's right

no

action may also be taken against those who abate under section fourteen c of the foreigners

because under the idr act section eighteen g is there

the application is absolutely silent on that

sibal just wondering if you could just look at the issues that were framed

yes

what are we witnessing around

that's the

a note has been uploaded for us on the screen

but the party who receives knows who has given

the constitution itself laid down the fetter's limitations on this power

the constituent assembly in india when it drafted the constitution can't have a life after the constitution is framed

then your lordships kindly skip the rest and my lord come to

limit

so we can follow that so that it won't overlap with one another

just only one second

my lords just a couple of dates

it deals with the period when the constitution assembly was

so to have clarity mr

that's right

now this declaration will be under entry fifty four

the problem still persists mr

mister malpe judgment is only on rent act and its validity

only for the parliament

and your lordships would not

this by itself is creating difficulties

it will also involve in what manner the minerals are to be used because now there is a generational intergenerational right concept introduced by this court internationally accepted

entry forty nine is 'tax on lands and buildings'

but they also have three four layers

sixty three

on viii a also i'll of course independently make my submission

therefore we have to simplify the procedure for ease of doing business

nothing turns on that you will not succeed or lose on this but the purpose was

it may not be fit for human consumptions as it is

the petition against the independent mla's were filed on the ground that they gave up their independent status by taking part in the resolution dated twenty first of june passed by the rebel mla's and signing the said resolution on the letterhead of sslp

we have no difficulty but for border fencing they cannot follow

section thirty one says that 'no person except the reserve bank of india or the central government can issue a bill of exchange promissory note or engagement for the payment of money payable to be

see my lords where we are now

and they had said you should have a plebiscite

which is why if you want to go to the election commission there has to be a split in the party

because one particular industry is separately mentioned

the formation of a constituent assembly is a political exercise to ensure that the people within the territory of a particular region their aspirations are taken into account to formulate a law and a constitution to ensure that those aspirations are met in future times to come

because when i argued this before the constitution bench then i said my lords what is happening is you let things happen and then you will tell me later that we can't reverse it

my lord for only this kindly allow me to use the physical copy

my lord one by my lord justice untwalia who was in majority four and minority by justice krishna iyer

the solicitor general has submitted on the instructions specific instructions of the union government that the union government has absolutely no intent to touch or affect