text
stringlengths 0
1.96k
|
|---|
"Perhaps I misunderstood something." "['non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non']" "paper quality" |
"Similarly, their 2D tasks showed only small differences in error rate, up to 2% at most.""" "['non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non']" "paper quality" |
"Second, 29% and 38% error seems alarmingly high" "['non', 'non', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con']" "paper quality" |
"The first study explores how users respond to new node ideas suggested by the tool and whether that creates more detailed maps." "['non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non']" "paper quality" |
"The second study expands on those findings to balance the depth and breadth of mind maps creation." "['non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non']" "paper quality" |
"Both studies compare the new mind mapping tool to digital options without computer assistance." "['non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non']" "paper quality" |
"The results are individually compelling , but what does it mean all together" "['pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'non', 'non', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con']" "paper quality" |
"What are the design choices" "['con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con']" "paper quality" |
"The system does not seem to follow a particular rationale" "['con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con']" "paper quality" |
"The fact that participants complained about the lack of information about syrup pouring reveals that this is more a trial and error approach than an informed design procedure" "['con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con']" "paper quality" |
"To which extent the system supports other patterns" "['con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con']" "paper quality" |
"For example between the hears and the leaf the syrup is either a series of dots or a continuous line." "['non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non']" "paper quality" |
"This inevitably has an effect on syrup pouring." "['non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non']" "paper quality" |
"The experiment procedure give little details about participants background" "['con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con']" "paper quality" |
"How did authors ensure homogeneity of the groups" "['con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con']" "paper quality" |
"The discussion mentions participants who felt the drawing were similar while the metric showed they were not" "['con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con']" "paper quality" |
"It read like some form of a haphazard account of few studies that point to the relevance of tracking and visualising patient data in order to inform better health decisions, and ultimately a better lifestyle" "['con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con']" "paper quality" |
"How representative is it , whats the bigger picture , can it be generalised to other not known scenarios" "['con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'non', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'non', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con']" "paper quality" |
"Although the issues of implication for design has been misunderstood and widely misrepresented, what the proposed design guideline sought to point to might be regarded as some form of outlining implications for a design practice that is minimal and non-representative" "['non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con']" "paper quality" |
"This makes the paper weak, lacking impactful significance , and thus leaning would not argue strongly towards acceptance." "['con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non']" "paper quality" |
"The authors then suggest some design guidelines at the end for developing usable patient data visualizations." "['non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non']" "paper quality" |
"I enjoyed the paper" "['pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro']" "paper quality" |
"I think these changes/clarifications can be made easily, and therefore I would argue for the acceptance of this paper pending these changes." "['non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non']" "paper quality" |
"While I appreciate the overall motivation , I'm not sure if a Fitts' law study is the right approach for going about understanding the effects of these kinds of interfaces" "['non', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'non', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con']" "paper quality" |
"The situation in which motor width differs from visual width seems fairly niche overall , and the examples cited in the introduction where visual width is greather than motor width seems like a situation that will almost always be due to poor interface implementation, rather than a conscious design decision" "['con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'non', 'non', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con']" "paper quality" |
"This is a nice paper that I believe proposes and novel and useful visualization scheme" "['pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro']" "paper quality" |
"The tool is a very useful and novel contribution , although I have some questions about the validity of the use case scenario" "['pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'non', 'non', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con']" "paper quality" |
"The latter assessed usability (SUS) and workload (NASA TLX) and custom miscellaneous items." "['non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non']" "paper quality" |
"Q10 only refers to realism - where is the immersion aspect coming from here?" "['non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non']" "paper quality" |
"The actual discussion of the results unfortunately is very limited (especially because large parts of it consist of qualitative reporting), and are mostly a summary, rather than a contextualization of the results within existing work, or statements on implications of the results" "['con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con']" "paper quality" |
"The paper does discuss limitations , but I think that this section should also address the fact that the study was largely preliminary / exploratory in nature ; there was no comparison condition, nor a discussion of what a baseline condition might look like for this context" "['pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'non', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con']" "paper quality" |
"Despite these weaknesses with regards to the study reporting and discussion, the paper is interesting and showcases good and novel work and I think the GI community would benefit from its presentation (albeit with some changes as suggested above)." "['non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non']" "paper quality" |
"The authors describe the design and implementation of a shape-based brushing technique targeted at selecting a particular type of data - trajectories." "['non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non']" "paper quality" |
"However, the paper is weakened by several writing and organizational aspects, and by an odd off-hand report of user feedback" "['non', 'non', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con']" "paper quality" |
"One main weakness of the paper is manifested here: I found the description of the bins, and how they are calculated, quite confusing" "['non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con']" "paper quality" |
"But this is not clear" "['non', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con']" "paper quality" |
"One would expect that trying some combination would be an obvious step , especially given the unclear feedback from the expert review." "['con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non']" "paper quality" |
"Having reviewed this approach with experts, the authors state that the experts did not get it, and so they choose to describe the system with a use-case method." "['non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non']" "paper quality" |
"Surely they found out useful information." "['non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non']" "paper quality" |
"RELATED WORK The related work is well balanced with a review on visualization dashboards and visualization in medical training with references from diverse related research communities" "['non', 'non', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro']" "paper quality" |
"Q1 can be reformulated with plural to avoid gender bias (so that this is harmonized with similar efforts along the paper)" "['con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con']" "paper quality" |
"VISUALIZATION DESIGN The rationale for visualization design is clearly explained and illustrated" "['non', 'non', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro']" "paper quality" |
"Congratulations for opensourcing the code to potentially help other institutions with medical programs (""across Canada"", or beyond?)." "['non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non']" "paper quality" |
"The responsive design choice is great for multiple device access with various form factors" "['pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro', 'pro']" "paper quality" |
"SUPPLEMENTARY VIDEO The video introduces the application domain and showcases diverse tasks supported by the tool presented in the submission." "['non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non']" "paper quality" |
"This paper discusses State Representation Learning for RL from camera images." "['non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non']" "paper quality" |
"The same problem also occurs for the conclusion about the robustness of SRL approaches" "['con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con']" "paper quality" |
"Because the parts of the state that are needed for multiple different prediction tasks (reconstruction, inverse model, etc.) need to be in the final state representation multiple times." "['non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'non']" "paper quality" |
"Minor points: - The choice for these tasks is not motivated well" "['non', 'non', 'non', 'non', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con']" "paper quality" |
"The GTC metric is not very well established (yet)" "['con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con', 'con']" "paper quality" |